The Subaru Crosstrek is among the most capable small crossovers you can buy, but the all-season tires it ships with are tuned for pavement, not dirt. Swap them for a proper all-terrain set and the Crosstrek suddenly handles gravel forest roads, muddy trailheads and snowy passes the way Subaru’s marketing always promised. The trick is finding an off-road tire that fits the Crosstrek’s modest sizes (typically 225/55R17, 225/60R17 or 225/55R18), respects its 8.7 inches of ground clearance and doesn’t turn a quiet commuter into a droning, gas-guzzling brick.
We focused on light-truck-style toughness in passenger-friendly sizes, weighing trail traction, snow performance, on-road manners, noise and tread life. Below are seven all-terrain and rugged-trail tires that genuinely exist in Crosstrek-correct sizes, ranked best first. Every pick is honest about its trade-offs, because a tire that crushes the trail but hums on the highway isn’t the right answer for a daily-driven Crosstrek.
| Photo | Product | Score | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
 |
Falken Wildpeak A/T Trail Best Overall All-terrain crossover tire, 3PMSF rated, 65,000-mile treadwear warranty |
9.5 |
ⓘ We may earn a commission from qualifying purchases made through links on this page, at no extra cost to you.
|
 |
BFGoodrich All-Terrain T/A KO2 Toughest Trail Build Light-truck all-terrain, CoreGard sidewall, 3PMSF rated |
9.3 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
Yokohama Geolandar A/T G015 Best All-Rounder All-terrain, 3PMSF rated, 60,000-mile treadwear warranty |
9.2 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
Cooper Discoverer AT3 4S Best Value Pick All-terrain four-season, 3PMSF rated, 60,000-mile warranty |
9.0 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
General Grabber A/TX Best Winter Grip All-terrain, 3PMSF rated, aggressive sidewall and shoulder design |
8.8 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
Toyo Open Country A/T III Longest Tread Life All-terrain, 3PMSF rated, up to 65,000-mile treadwear warranty |
8.6 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
Nokian Outpost AT Best for Harsh Climates All-terrain, 3PMSF rated, Aramid-reinforced sidewall |
8.4 | 🛒 Check Price |
1. Falken Wildpeak A/T Trail: Best Overall
The Wildpeak A/T Trail is the tire Falken designed specifically for crossovers and compact SUVs, which makes it almost a factory match for the Crosstrek’s mission. It uses a passenger (P-metric) construction rather than a heavy light-truck casing, so it doesn’t blunt the Crosstrek’s steering or fuel economy the way a chunkier tire would. On gravel and packed dirt it grips confidently, and the open shoulder blocks claw through loose forest-road surfaces without ever feeling vague on pavement. The Three-Peak Mountain Snowflake rating is the headline feature for Subaru owners in snow country, and in practice it backs that badge up with strong winter bite.
Where it shows its limits is deep, sticky mud and rock crawling, neither of which a Crosstrek should really attempt anyway. The tread voids are tuned for all-terrain versatility, not maximum self-cleaning, so a true bog will pack the lugs faster than an aggressive mud-terrain would. You also feel a small step up in firmness over the soft stock tire, though most owners describe it as planted rather than harsh. For the overwhelming majority of Crosstrek drivers who mix daily commuting with weekend trails and winter, this is the tire to buy first.
- Purpose-built for crossovers like the Crosstrek, not a shrunken truck tire
- Three-Peak Mountain Snowflake rated for real winter and deep snow traction
- Available in 225/55R17, 225/60R17 and 225/55R18 to fit factory Crosstrek wheels
Pros: Outstanding balance of trail grip and quiet on-road ride; Genuine snow and ice capability with the 3PMSF rating; Long treadwear warranty for an off-road-capable tire
Cons: Not as aggressive in deep mud as a true light-truck A/T; Slightly firmer ride than the stock all-season tire
2. BFGoodrich All-Terrain T/A KO2: Toughest Trail Build
The KO2 is the tire people picture when they hear the words off-road, and for good reason. Its CoreGard technology extends the rubber down the sidewall and uses a split-and-bruise resistant compound, which is exactly what you want when a sharp rock catches the edge of the tire on a rutted trail. The aggressive tread digs into mud, gravel and rock far better than any crossover-specific tire, and the serrated shoulder gives the Crosstrek extra bite when one wheel drops into a loose berm. It carries the 3PMSF snow rating too, so it’s no slouch in winter.
The honest weakness is that the KO2 is a light-truck tire asked to do a crossover’s job. In Crosstrek sizes it’s heavier than the alternatives here, and that mass shows up as slower acceleration, a small fuel-economy penalty and more road noise at highway speed. If your Crosstrek genuinely sees rough, rocky terrain and trail damage is your biggest fear, that trade is worth it. If you mostly drive pavement and want trail insurance, lighter picks on this list ride and sound better.
- Legendary CoreGard sidewall resists cuts and punctures on rocky trails
- Aggressive tread pattern self-cleans in mud and loose dirt
- Available in 225/55R18 and 225/60R17 fitments for the Crosstrek
Pros: Class-leading durability and sidewall protection; Excellent grip in mud, rock and gravel; Proven, trusted reputation among serious off-roaders
Cons: Heavier than passenger tires, so it dulls fuel economy and acceleration; Noticeably louder on the highway than crossover-tuned options
3. Yokohama Geolandar A/T G015: Best All-Rounder
The Geolandar A/T G015 is Yokohama’s answer to drivers who want all-terrain looks and capability without sacrificing on-road comfort, and that brief fits the Crosstrek perfectly. It’s one of the quietest tires in this roundup, with a tread pattern engineered to suppress the droning hum that plagues lesser A/T tires. The triple-3D sipe design gives it genuine wet-weather and snow grip, and it carries the 3PMSF rating so it’s trustworthy when the weather turns. On gravel and dirt it’s sure-footed, and the even wear means the long warranty is realistic rather than optimistic.
Its softer, more road-biased character is also its limitation off-road. In deep mud or really loose, churned-up ground, the G015 doesn’t claw quite as hard as the KO2 or a rugged-terrain tire, and the lugs can pack rather than fling debris. For a Crosstrek that spends most of its life on pavement and gravel with occasional rougher detours, that’s a fair compromise and arguably the smart one. Push deep into a serious trail regularly, though, and you’ll want something more aggressive.
- Quiet, comfortable ride that suits a daily-driven Crosstrek
- Triple 3D sipes deliver strong wet and snow traction
- Offered in 225/55R17, 225/60R17 and 225/55R18 sizes
Pros: Very quiet and refined for an all-terrain tire; Reliable winter and wet-road grip; Long treadwear warranty and even wear
Cons: Trail traction trails the most aggressive options here; Tread can feel less planted in deep mud
4. Cooper Discoverer AT3 4S: Best Value Pick
The Discoverer AT3 4S is Cooper’s four-season all-terrain tire, and the 4S in the name signals it’s the variant tuned for drivers who want winter capability baked in. For the Crosstrek that means a single tire you can leave on year-round across most of North America. Cooper’s Whisper Grooves help tame the noise that all-terrain tread can generate, so the ride stays civilized on long highway stretches, while the adaptive-traction tread keeps things composed on wet pavement, light snow and gravel back roads. It carries the 3PMSF badge and represents a lot of capability for the value.
It’s, however, an all-terrain tire aimed at the comfortable middle of the segment rather than the aggressive end. Deep mud, rock gardens and serious trail abuse are outside its comfort zone, and the steering response feels a touch softer and less precise than the Falken or Yokohama. None of that matters much for the typical Crosstrek owner exploring fire roads and snowy passes. If you want a sensible, capable, well-rounded tire without overpaying, the AT3 4S earns its spot.
- Whisper Grooves reduce road noise for a calmer cabin
- Adaptive-Traction tread grips wet, dry, snow and gravel
- Available in passenger sizes that fit the Crosstrek's 17 and 18-inch wheels
Pros: Strong all-around performance for the value; Good noise control and ride comfort; Dependable four-season and light-trail traction
Cons: Not built for extreme mud or rock crawling; Steering feel is slightly softer than premium rivals
5. General Grabber A/TX: Best Winter Grip
The Grabber A/TX is General Tire’s more aggressive all-terrain, and it stands out for cold-weather grip that genuinely impresses Crosstrek owners in snow-belt states. The siped, biting tread blocks dig into snow and ice, and the 3PMSF rating is well earned in real winter driving. Off the pavement, the DuraGen construction brings real cut-and-chip resistance, so gravel showers and rocky trailheads don’t chew up the tread, and the aggressive shoulder lugs give the Crosstrek a confident, planted feel on loose surfaces. It also looks the part, which matters to owners who have lifted their Crosstrek.
That toughness comes with the usual costs. The A/TX is louder and firmer than the Falken Wildpeak A/T Trail or Yokohama G015, and on smooth highway it generates more of that characteristic all-terrain hum. The heavier build also nibbles a little at fuel economy and acceleration, which a 152-horsepower Crosstrek feels more than a big truck would. If winter traction and trail toughness top your list and you accept some refinement loss, the Grabber A/TX is a strong, rugged choice.
- DuraGen construction adds cut and chip resistance for trails
- Strong snow and ice traction with siped, biting tread blocks
- Comes in 225/60R17 and 225/55R18 fitments for the Crosstrek
Pros: Excellent cold-weather and snow performance; Tough construction handles gravel and rocky roads well; Aggressive, rugged appearance that suits a lifted Crosstrek
Cons: Louder and firmer than crossover-tuned tires; Heavier build slightly reduces fuel economy
6. Toyo Open Country A/T III: Longest Tread Life
The Open Country A/T III is Toyo’s latest revision of a long-running all-terrain favorite, and the headline for Crosstrek owners is longevity. The high-density tread compound and the up-to-65,000-mile warranty mean this is a tire you can fit and forget for years of mixed driving. The redesigned tread pattern is noticeably quieter than the previous A/T II, the open shoulder blocks handle gravel and mud respectably, and the 3PMSF rating means it’s legitimately winter-rated rather than just snow-friendly. It strikes a sensible balance for owners who rack up miles and want value over a long ownership window.
In direct comparison, its snow grip is good but not best-in-class, trailing the General Grabber A/TX and Falken in deep winter conditions, and it’s neither the quietest nor the most affordable choice on this list. It also leans slightly toward on-road manners, so dedicated trail riders may want something more aggressive. But if your priority is a durable, dependable tire that wears slowly and behaves itself everywhere, the Open Country A/T III is a smart long-haul pick for the Crosstrek.
- High-density tread compound for long, even wear
- Open shoulder blocks improve traction in mud and gravel
- Available in Crosstrek-friendly 225/55R18 and 225/60R17 sizes
Pros: Long treadwear warranty and durable compound; Solid all-season and light-trail traction; Refreshed tread pattern runs quieter than the previous version
Cons: Mid-pack snow performance versus the best winter tires here; Not the cheapest or the quietest in the group
7. Nokian Outpost AT: Best for Harsh Climates
Nokian built its reputation in the harsh climates of Finland, and the Outpost AT brings that severe-weather pedigree to crossover owners. For a Crosstrek driver who battles real winters and rough gravel back roads, this tire is in its element: the cold-weather compound stays pliable when temperatures plunge, and the Aramid-reinforced sidewall (the same fiber family used in protective gear) shrugs off the sharp gravel and hidden rocks that puncture lesser tires. Despite that toughness, it rides in a surprisingly controlled, comfortable way, so it doesn’t punish you on the commute.
The two honest caveats are availability and aggression. Nokian has a smaller dealer footprint than the household names here, so finding your exact Crosstrek size in stock can take more effort. And while the Outpost AT is excellent on gravel and in winter, it’s tuned more for durability and bad-weather control than for clawing through deep mud, so hardcore trail users will find it milder than a KO2. For cold, rocky, gravel-heavy regions, though, it’s a brilliant and underrated choice.
- Aramid sidewall technology resists impacts and punctures
- Engineered by a Nordic brand for severe winter and gravel
- Offered in 225/55R17 and 225/60R17 sizes for the Crosstrek
Pros: Exceptional cold-weather and gravel-road performance; Tough Aramid-reinforced sidewalls for rough terrain; Comfortable, controlled ride for an all-terrain tire
Cons: Less common in stores, so availability can vary; Trail traction is milder than aggressive truck-style tires
Frequently Asked Questions
What tire size do I need for off-road tires on a Subaru Crosstrek?
Most Subaru Crosstrek trims use 225/55R17 or 225/60R17 on 17-inch wheels, while Sport, Limited and Wilderness-style trims often run 225/55R18 on 18-inch wheels. Always check the placard inside your driver’s door jamb or the sidewall of your current tires to confirm the exact size before ordering. Staying within the factory size keeps your speedometer accurate and avoids rubbing, and every tire in this guide is available in at least one of those Crosstrek fitments.
Will all-terrain tires hurt my Crosstrek's fuel economy?
Yes, slightly, but how much depends on the tire. Crossover-tuned all-terrains like the Falken Wildpeak A/T Trail and Yokohama Geolandar A/T G015 use lighter passenger construction and shave only a small amount off your mpg. Heavier light-truck options like the BFGoodrich KO2 add more rolling resistance and weight, so you’ll feel a bigger dip in economy and acceleration on the Crosstrek’s modest engine. If fuel economy matters most to you, lean toward the lighter, crossover-specific picks.
Do I need the 3PMSF snow rating for my Crosstrek?
If you drive in real winter conditions, the Three-Peak Mountain Snowflake rating is well worth prioritizing. It certifies that the tire met a measured snow-traction standard, which is more meaningful than a generic M+S marking. Every tire in this roundup carries the 3PMSF rating, so you get genuine snow capability alongside off-road grip. If you live somewhere that never sees snow, the rating matters less, but it rarely hurts to have it on an all-wheel-drive Subaru.
Can a stock Subaru Crosstrek fit all-terrain tires without a lift?
In the factory sizes listed here, yes. Because these tires come in standard Crosstrek dimensions, they bolt on without a lift, fender modification or speedometer recalibration. A lift kit lets you fit larger or more aggressive tires for serious trail use, but it isn’t required for any of the recommendations in this guide. Sticking to the stock size is the easiest, most reliable way to add off-road capability to a daily-driven Crosstrek.
How loud are off-road tires on a Crosstrek at highway speed?
It varies a lot by design. Crossover-focused all-terrains such as the Yokohama Geolandar A/T G015 and Cooper Discoverer AT3 4S use noise-reducing tread patterns and stay close to a normal car tire on the highway. More aggressive light-truck tires like the BFGoodrich KO2 and General Grabber A/TX produce a noticeable hum that grows as the tread wears. If a quiet cabin is a priority, choose one of the quieter picks and rotate your tires regularly to keep wear even and noise down.
Our Verdict
For most Subaru Crosstrek owners, the Falken Wildpeak A/T Trail is the clear top pick. It was engineered for crossovers like the Crosstrek, balances real trail and snow capability with a quiet, comfortable on-road ride, and comes in every common factory size, which makes it the smartest single upgrade you can make. If your driving leans toward genuinely rough, rocky terrain where sidewall damage is the real worry, the BFGoodrich All-Terrain T/A KO2 is the runner up, trading some refinement and fuel economy for class-leading toughness. Match the tire to how you actually drive, stick to your factory size, and your Crosstrek will finally live up to its adventurous reputation.
More Tires Guides
Video Guide
Video: Related tutorial from YouTube