After researching manufacturer specifications, industry safety standards, and aggregated owner feedback across dozens of models, we identified the seven best hitch tire carriers on the market. Our evaluation focuses on load capacity, vibration control, ease of installation, and long-term durability. Whether you need a simple spare tire mount for your SUV or a heavy-duty carrier for off-road adventures, this guide will help you choose the right one.
| Photo | Product | Score | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
 |
Rugged Ridge 11551.35 Spare Tire Carrier Best Overall Fits 2-inch hitch, 500 lbs load capacity |
9.0 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
Yakima SpareTime Hitch-Mount Bike Rack Best for Bikes Fits 2-inch hitch, 2-bike capacity, 120 lbs max |
8.7 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
Smittybilt 44811 Tire Carrier Best Heavy-Duty Fits 2-inch hitch, 750 lbs capacity |
8.4 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
CURT 18106 Hitch Mounted Spare Tire Carrier Best Value Fits 2-inch hitch, 300 lbs capacity |
8.1 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
MaxxHaul 70731 Hitch Mount Tire Carrier Lightweight Option Fits 2-inch hitch, 350 lbs capacity |
7.8 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
Tyger Auto TG-HC6S Hitch Mount Cargo Carrier Cargo Combo Fits 2-inch hitch, 500 lbs capacity, 60×20 inch platform |
7.3 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
BAL 28050 Hidden Hitch Spare Tire Carrier Compact Design Fits 2-inch hitch, 300 lbs capacity, fits tires up to 31 inches |
7.0 | 🛒 Check Price |
1. Rugged Ridge 11551.35 Spare Tire Carrier: Best Overall
Based on owner feedback and the spec sheets, the Rugged Ridge 11551.35 stands out for its sturdy build and excellent load capacity of 500 pounds. The adjustable plate accommodates tires up to 37 inches, making it all-around for most SUVs and trucks. The anti-rattle bolt helps reduce vibration during driving, a common complaint with hitch carriers.
However, its weight (over 50 pounds) can be a drawback for those who frequently remove it. It also requires some assembly. If you want a lighter option or have a smaller vehicle, consider a more compact model. But for full-size rigs, this is our top pick.
- Heavy-duty steel construction with black powder coat finish
- Adjustable mounting plate fits tires up to 37 inches
- Anti-rattle bolt and lockable hitch pin included
Pros: Very sturdy with minimal wobble; Easy to install and adjust
Cons: Heavy at over 50 pounds
2. Yakima SpareTime Hitch-Mount Bike Rack: Best for Bikes
We researched the Yakima SpareTime as a top choice for bike transport. Its platform design makes loading and unloading bikes easy, and the integrated anti-sway cradles keep bikes secure. The fold-up feature is handy for storage and access to the rear hatch.
However, this carrier is designed specifically for bikes, not spare tires. If you need a tire carrier, this is not it. It also has a lower weight limit (120 pounds) and cannot carry heavy loads. For dedicated bike hauling, it is excellent, but skip it if you need a spare tire mount.
- Hitch-mounted platform style with wheel straps
- Integrated anti-sway cradles
- Folds up when not in use
Pros: Very easy to load bikes; Compact fold-up design
Cons: Not for tires or heavy cargo
3. Smittybilt 44811 Tire Carrier: Best Heavy-Duty
In our evaluation of heavy-duty options, the Smittybilt 44811 excels with a 750-pound capacity and support for tires up to 40 inches. The all-steel construction and durable welds inspire confidence for off-road use. Owner feedback highlights its ability to handle abuse on rough trails.
But its weight (over 60 pounds) and size make it cumbersome to install and remove. It also tends to rattle more on pavement despite the anti-rattle bolt. If you drive mostly on-road or need something lighter, look elsewhere. For serious off-roaders with large tires, it is a top contender.
- All-steel construction with heavy-duty welds
- Adjustable tire mount fits up to 40-inch tires
- Locking hitch pin and anti-rattle bolt
Pros: Extremely durable, handles large tires; Very high load capacity
Cons: Very heavy and bulky; Installation can be difficult alone
4. CURT 18106 Hitch Mounted Spare Tire Carrier: Best Value
Based on owner feedback and the spec sheets, the CURT 18106 offers a budget-friendly solution for carrying a spare tire. It fits tires up to 33 inches and has a 300-pound capacity, enough for most standard spares. Installation is straightforward with basic tools.
However, its lighter construction leads to more wobble on uneven terrain, and the 300-pound limit may not suit larger tires or additional gear. If you carry a heavy off-road tire, consider a heavier-duty model. For everyday use with a standard spare, it is a great value.
- Simple bolt-on design, no drilling required
- Fits tires up to 33 inches
- Includes hitch pin and anti-rattle bolt
Pros: Affordable and good value; Easy to install
Cons: Lower weight capacity; Some wobble reported on rough roads
5. MaxxHaul 70731 Hitch Mount Tire Carrier: Lightweight Option
We researched the MaxxHaul 70731 as a lightweight alternative for those who need to occasionally carry a spare. Its hybrid construction keeps weight down, and the foldable design allows easy storage. It fits tires up to 35 inches and has a 350-pound capacity.
However, its lighter build leads to more vibration and wobble, especially at highway speeds. It is not as strong as all-steel carriers and may not hold up to frequent off-road use. If you need a permanent heavy-duty solution, skip this. For occasional use on paved roads, it is adequate.
- Aluminum and steel hybrid construction
- Fits tires up to 35 inches
- Foldable design for storage
Pros: Lightweight and easy to handle; Foldable when not in use
Cons: Less durable than all-steel models; May wobble at highway speeds
6. Tyger Auto TG-HC6S Hitch Mount Cargo Carrier: Cargo Combo
Based on owner feedback and the spec sheets, the Tyger Auto TG-HC6S is a multi-purpose hitch carrier that can hold a spare tire along with other gear. Its large platform (60×20 inches) and 500-pound capacity make it multi-purpose. It folds up when not in use.
However, it is not designed specifically for tires, so securing a round tire can be tricky. The included cargo net is not very durable. If you primarily need a dedicated tire carrier, look elsewhere. For those who want to carry a tire plus coolers or boxes, it offers flexibility but with compromises.
- Expanded metal platform for cargo and tires
- Includes cargo net and tie-downs
- Folding design for storage
Pros: Flexible for cargo and tires; Large platform
Cons: Not dedicated tire carrier, less secure; Cargo net is flimsy
7. BAL 28050 Hidden Hitch Spare Tire Carrier: Compact Design
We researched the BAL 28050 as a compact option for small spare tires. Its low-profile design keeps the tire close to the vehicle, reducing leverage and wobble. It fits tires up to 31 inches and has a 300-pound capacity.
However, its small size limits its usefulness for larger tires common on trucks and SUVs. The lower capacity (300 pounds) and lighter construction mean it is not as stable on rough roads. If you have a compact SUV with a small spare, it may work. For larger vehicles, consider a more solid carrier.
- Low-profile design, minimal rear protrusion
- Adjustable mounting post
- Includes hitch pin
Pros: Compact and unobtrusive; Good for small spare tires
Cons: Limited tire size compatibility; Lower capacity and stability
Frequently Asked Questions
Will a hitch tire carrier affect my vehicle's rear visibility or backup sensors?
Yes, a hitch tire carrier can partially block rear visibility and may interfere with backup sensors if the tire is close to the bumper. Many carriers have an offset design to minimize this, but it is worth checking the dimensions. Some users report that sensors may trigger false alerts. Adjusting the tire position or using a carrier with a tilting feature can help.
How do I prevent wobble and vibration with a hitch tire carrier?
Wobble is a common issue. To reduce it, use a carrier with an anti-rattle bolt or a stabilizer. Ensure the hitch pin is tight and consider adding a hitch tightener or wedge. Some carriers have a dual-bolt design for extra stability. On rough roads, heavier carriers tend to wobble less, but proper installation is key.
Can I use a hitch tire carrier with a trailer hitch cover or bike rack simultaneously?
Most hitch tire carriers occupy the full receiver, so you cannot use another accessory at the same time unless you have a dual-hitch adapter. However, some carriers have a built-in receiver extension for a bike rack or cargo tray. Check the product specifications for this feature.
What is the maximum tire size I can fit on a hitch tire carrier?
It depends on the carrier model. Most standard carriers fit tires up to 33-35 inches, while heavy-duty models can accommodate up to 40 inches. Always measure your tire’s diameter and width before purchasing. Also consider the offset and clearance from the vehicle’s rear.
Are hitch tire carriers legal for highway use?
Yes, they are legal in most states as long as they do not obstruct license plates, taillights, or turn signals. Some carriers include a license plate mount and wiring harness for lights. It is your responsibility to ensure visibility and compliance with local laws. Check state regulations regarding rear load protrusion.
Our Verdict
After researching and comparing, the Rugged Ridge 11551.35 is our top pick for its balance of strength, adjustability, and anti-rattle design. For a budget-friendly option, the CURT 18106 offers good value for standard spare tires. If you need a heavy-duty carrier for large off-road tires, the Smittybilt 44811 is the best choice despite its weight.
More Tires Guides
Video Guide
Video: Related tutorial from YouTube