We researched and compared Buick Encore model years using manufacturer specifications, published safety ratings from the IIHS and NHTSA, and aggregated owner feedback from forums and reliability surveys. Our evaluation focuses on mechanical reliability, common issues, and overall owner satisfaction to help you choose the best used Buick Encore. Below are our top picks and years to approach with caution.
| Photo | Product | Score | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
|
🚗
|
Buick Encore 2019 Best Overall Year 1.4L turbo I4, 153 hp, 6-speed automatic, FWD/AWD |
9.0 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Buick Encore 2020 Runner Up 1.4L turbo I4, 153 hp, 6-speed automatic, FWD/AWD |
8.7 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Buick Encore 2017 Budget Pick 1.4L turbo I4, 138 hp, 6-speed automatic, FWD/AWD |
8.4 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Buick Encore 2018 Decent Choice 1.4L turbo I4, 138 hp, 6-speed automatic, FWD/AWD |
8.1 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Buick Encore 2015 Mixed Reliability 1.4L turbo I4, 138 hp, 6-speed automatic, FWD/AWD |
7.8 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Buick Encore 2016 Avoid if Possible 1.4L turbo I4, 138 hp, 6-speed automatic, FWD/AWD |
7.3 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Buick Encore 2013 Worst Year 1.4L turbo I4, 138 hp, 6-speed automatic, FWD |
7.0 | 🛒 Check Price |
1. Buick Encore 2019: Best Overall Year
The 2019 Buick Encore stands out as the best model year in our research. It earned the IIHS Top Safety Pick and a 5-star NHTSA overall rating. Owner feedback indicates fewer mechanical complaints compared to earlier years, with the 1.4L turbo engine proving durable when maintained. The updated infotainment system with smartphone integration adds daily convenience.
However, the interior still uses hard plastics, and the back seat is cramped for taller passengers. If you prioritize a premium cabin or need ample rear legroom, consider a larger SUV. This year is ideal for buyers seeking a safe, reliable subcompact crossover with modern tech.
- Top safety ratings from IIHS and NHTSA
- Improved infotainment with Apple CarPlay and Android Auto
- Reliable 1.4L turbo engine with fewer reported issues
Pros: Excellent safety scores; Modern infotainment system; Good reliability record
Cons: Interior materials feel a bit cheap; Rear seat space is tight for adults
2. Buick Encore 2020: Runner Up
The 2020 Buick Encore carries over the 2019’s strengths with added standard safety features like forward collision alert and lane keep assist. In our evaluation, owner satisfaction remains high, and reliability reports are positive. The cabin is notably quiet on the highway, a plus for daily commuting.
That said, it’s essentially the same car as the 2019, so you won’t gain much by spending extra. Cargo space behind the rear seats is only 18.8 cubic feet, limiting utility. If you need more room or want the latest design, look at the Encore GX or other competitors. The 2020 is best for those who value safety and a quiet ride in a small package.
- Standard rearview camera and forward collision alert
- Quiet cabin for the class
- Same proven powertrain as 2019
Pros: Strong safety suite standard; Refined ride quality; Good fuel economy
Cons: No major changes from 2019; Cargo space is limited
3. Buick Encore 2017: Budget Pick
The 2017 Buick Encore offers good value for those on a budget. Based on aggregated owner feedback, it has fewer major issues than earlier models, though some report coolant leaks from the turbo coolant lines. The 1.4L engine is adequate for city driving but feels underpowered on the highway. Safety ratings are solid but not class-leading.
Potential buyers should check service records for coolant system repairs. The infotainment lacks Apple CarPlay and Android Auto, which may be a dealbreaker for tech-savvy users. This year is a sensible choice if you find a well-maintained example at a attractive price and can live without modern connectivity.
- Lower price point for budget-conscious buyers
- Decent reliability with proper maintenance
- Available AWD for all-weather traction
Pros: Affordable used pricing; AWD option; Comfortable front seats
Cons: Outdated infotainment system; Some owners report coolant leaks
4. Buick Encore 2018: Decent Choice
The 2018 Buick Encore received a mild refresh with a bolder grille and upgraded interior trim. In our research, owner satisfaction is moderate, with praise for the comfortable ride but criticism for the dated technology. Reliability is average, with some complaints about transmission hesitation and infotainment glitches.
It’s a step up from 2017 but not as refined as 2019. If you can find a 2019 at a similar price, we recommend skipping the 2018. However, for buyers who prioritize a quieter cabin and slightly nicer materials over tech, the 2018 remains a viable option.
- Minor styling refresh with new grille
- Standard rearview camera
- Improved interior materials over 2017
Pros: Slightly nicer interior; Good safety scores; Smooth ride
Cons: Still uses older infotainment; Engine can feel sluggish
5. Buick Encore 2015: Mixed Reliability
The 2015 Buick Encore is among the most affordable years, but our research reveals a higher frequency of transmission problems and coolant leaks compared to later years. Owner forums report jerky shifts and premature failure in some units. Safety ratings are decent, but the car lacks modern driver assists.
We recommend this year only if you have a tight budget and are prepared for potential repairs. A thorough pre-purchase inspection by a mechanic is essential. Skip it if you want worry-free ownership or plan to keep the car long-term. For most buyers, spending a bit more on a 2017 or newer is wiser.
- Lowest used prices of the generation
- Available with AWD
- Compact size easy to park
Pros: Very affordable; Easy maneuverability; Good fuel economy
Cons: Frequent complaints about transmission issues; Infotainment system is slow and dated
6. Buick Encore 2016: Avoid if Possible
The 2016 Buick Encore has a poor reliability record in our evaluation. Aggregated owner feedback and J.D. Power data indicate a higher than normal rate of engine stalling, rough idling, and check engine light issues. While not all cars are affected, the risk is notable. Safety ratings are acceptable, but the driving experience is marred by powertrain concerns.
We advise most buyers to avoid the 2016 model unless it comes with a comprehensive warranty and a significant price discount. Even then, the reassurance may not be worth it. Consider a 2017 or later for better dependability.
- Minor year with few updates
- Some owners report engine stalling
- Low reliability scores from J.D. Power
Pros: Low purchase price; Available AWD; Decent fuel economy
Cons: Stalling and hesitation issues; Below-average reliability rating
7. Buick Encore 2013: Worst Year
The 2013 Buick Encore is the first year of the model and suffers from the most problems. Our research shows extensive recalls for engine cooling fans, electrical shorts, and transmission software. Owner complaints are common for premature brake wear, infotainment failures, and excessive oil consumption. Safety ratings are average, but the reliability is a major concern.
We strongly recommend avoiding the 2013 model. Even with a low price, the potential for costly repairs outweighs any savings. Later years, especially 2019 and 2020, offer far better reliability and owner satisfaction. If you’re considering a 2013, we urge you to look at other options.
- First model year with many teething problems
- Numerous recalls for engine and electrical issues
- Lowest owner satisfaction scores
Pros: Unique styling; Compact size; Lowest price point
Cons: Multiple recalls and TSBs; Poor reliability and high repair costs
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the most reliable Buick Encore year?
Based on our research, the 2019 Buick Encore is the most reliable year. It has the fewest owner complaints, highest safety ratings, and improved infotainment. The 2020 is also very reliable but offers minimal changes.
Which Buick Encore years should I avoid?
We recommend avoiding the 2013, 2015, and 2016 model years. The 2013 has numerous recalls, the 2015 has transmission issues, and the 2016 suffers from engine stalling and poor reliability scores.
Is the Buick Encore expensive to maintain?
Maintenance costs for the Buick Encore are average for the subcompact SUV class. However, earlier years (2013-2016) may have higher repair costs due to common issues like coolant leaks and transmission problems. Later years (2017+) are generally more affordable to maintain.
Does the Buick Encore have good safety ratings?
Yes, the Buick Encore generally performs well in safety tests. The 2019 and 2020 models earned IIHS Top Safety Pick and NHTSA 5-star overall ratings. Earlier years have good but not top-tier scores.
What is the difference between Buick Encore and Encore GX?
The Buick Encore GX is a larger, more refined model introduced for 2020. It offers more cargo space, a more powerful engine option, and a modern interior. The standard Encore is smaller and less expensive. For used buyers, the Encore is more affordable, while the GX is better for those needing more space.
Our Verdict
After researching and comparing Buick Encore model years, we recommend the 2019 as the top pick for its excellent safety, reliability, and modern features. The 2020 is a close runner-up if you want the latest standard safety tech. For budget buyers, the 2017 offers decent value but requires careful inspection. Avoid the 2013, 2015, and 2016 years due to higher problem rates.
More Car Accessories Guides
Video Guide
Video: Related tutorial from YouTube