We researched and compared the top spare tire covers on the market, evaluating materials, UV resistance, fitment, and owner satisfaction. Our guide covers hard and soft covers for various tire sizes, from universal fits to custom-molded options. Whether you need protection for a Jeep Wrangler, truck, or SUV, we break down the strengths and weaknesses of each pick based on spec sheets and real owner feedback.
| Photo | Product | Score | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
 |
Covercraft UVS100 Custom Fit Spare Tire Cover Best Overall Custom fit for specific tire sizes, UV-resistant polyester with fleece backing |
9.4 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Rugged Ridge 13360.11 Black Spare Tire Cover Best for Jeeps Fits 35×12.50R15 to 37×12.50R17 tires, heavy-duty vinyl |
8.7 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
Leader Accessories Black Heavy Duty Spare Tire Cover Best Value Universal fit for tires up to 35 inches, 600D Oxford fabric |
8.2 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
OEDRO Spare Tire Cover Premium Material Fits tires 31-33 inches, 900D Oxford fabric with PU coating |
8.1 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
Dee Zee DZ8746 Spare Tire Cover Truck Fit Fits tires 32-35 inches, heavy-duty vinyl with fleece lining |
7.8 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
Tyger Auto TG-SP1S3001 Spare Tire Cover Universal Fit Fits tires 29-33 inches, 600D polyester with PVC backing |
7.3 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
Smittybilt 49651 Spare Tire Cover Off-Road Ready Fits 35-37 inch tires, heavy-duty vinyl with stitched seams |
7.2 | 🛒 Check Price |
1. Covercraft UVS100 Custom Fit Spare Tire Cover: Best Overall
We researched the Covercraft UVS100 and found it to be the top performer for those seeking a tailored fit and long-term protection. The UV-resistant polyester and fleece backing guard against sun and ozone cracking, a common failure point on cheaper covers. Owner feedback highlights its snug fit and resistance to fading even after multiple seasons. Based on spec sheets, it is available for dozens of tire sizes, making it a all-around choice for many vehicles.
However, the premium price may not suit budget-conscious buyers. If you rarely park in direct sunlight or prefer a quick universal solution, consider a lower-cost alternative. The UVS100 is best for owners who want maximum protection and a custom look.
- Custom fit ensures minimal flapping and secure attachment
- UV-resistant fabric with fleece lining protects tire from sun damage
- Easy to install with elastic hem and drawstring
Pros: Excellent UV protection and durability; Custom fit for plenty of tire sizes
Cons: Higher price point compared to universal covers
2. Rugged Ridge 13360.11 Black Spare Tire Cover: Best for Jeeps
In our evaluation, the Rugged Ridge 13360.11 stands out for Jeep owners running oversized tires. The heavy-duty vinyl is thicker than many universal covers, and owner reviews note it stays put on rough trails. We compared its material to similar covers and found it offers above-average puncture resistance. The elastic cord and toggle system makes installation straightforward, even with gloves on.
That said, this cover is not suitable for smaller tires or vehicles other than Jeeps. If you have a stock spare or drive a truck, look for a more universal option. Some owners reported slight fading after a year of intense sun, so UV protection is adequate but not best-in-class.
- Heavy-duty vinyl construction resists tears and weather
- Specifically designed for lifted Jeeps with larger tires
- Easy on/off with elastic cord and toggle
Pros: Durable material holds up well off-road; Good fit for oversized tires
Cons: Limited to larger tire sizes; not for stock tires
3. Leader Accessories Black Heavy Duty Spare Tire Cover: Best Value
We researched the Leader Accessories cover and found it to be a solid budget option. The 600D Oxford fabric with PVC coating provides decent water and UV protection, and owner feedback indicates it fits most tires up to 35 inches without excessive looseness. Based on spec sheets, it is one of the lightest covers we evaluated, making it easy to handle during installation and removal.
However, the material is thinner than premium alternatives, and some owners reported tearing after a few seasons in harsh climates. If you need a cover for occasional use or mild weather, this is a great choice. For full-time outdoor parking in extreme sun, consider a higher-end model. Skip it if you want a custom fit or heavy-duty off-road durability.
- 600D Oxford fabric with PVC coating for water resistance
- Elastic hem with adjustable strap for secure fit
- Lightweight and easy to fold for storage
Pros: Affordable without sacrificing basic protection; Good water resistance for the price
Cons: Not as durable as premium covers; may show wear in 2-3 years
4. OEDRO Spare Tire Cover: Premium Material
Our evaluation of the OEDRO cover highlights its premium 900D fabric, which is thicker and more abrasion-resistant than typical 600D covers. The PU coating provides excellent water repellency, and the double-stitched seams reduce the risk of unraveling. Owner reviews praise its snug fit on standard SUV and truck tires (31-33 inches). The reflective strip is a thoughtful addition for safety, especially on dark roads.
However, the limited size range means it won’t fit larger off-road tires or smaller spares. Some owners noted that the elastic hem can loosen over time, requiring occasional adjustment. If your tire size falls within the range and you prioritize material quality, this is a strong contender. Skip it if you need a custom fit for non-standard sizes.
- 900D Oxford fabric with PU coating for enhanced water resistance
- Double-stitched seams for added durability
- Reflective strip for nighttime visibility
Pros: Thicker fabric than many competitors; Reflective strip adds safety
Cons: Limited size range; not for tires over 33 inches
5. Dee Zee DZ8746 Spare Tire Cover: Truck Fit
We compared the Dee Zee DZ8746 and found it to be a reliable option for truck owners. The heavy-duty vinyl with fleece lining prevents the cover from scratching the wheel, a common issue with cheaper covers. The elastic hem and locking drawstring keep it secure at highway speeds. Owner feedback indicates it holds up well in moderate climates, with minimal fading after a year.
However, the vinyl can stiffen in freezing temperatures, making installation more difficult. Some users also reported that the cover is slightly larger than advertised, leading to a loose fit on smaller tires. If you live in a cold region or have a tire at the lower end of the size range, consider a more flexible material. This cover is best for trucks in mild weather.
- Heavy-duty vinyl with fleece lining to prevent scratching
- Elastic hem with locking drawstring
- Specifically designed for truck spares
Pros: Fleece lining protects tire and wheel from scratches; Good fit for common truck tire sizes
Cons: Vinyl can become stiff in cold weather
6. Tyger Auto TG-SP1S3001 Spare Tire Cover: Universal Fit
In our research, the Tyger Auto TG-SP1S3001 is a basic universal cover that gets the job done for a low price. The 600D polyester with PVC backing provides some protection from rain and dust, but owner reviews note that it can fade and become brittle after a few months of direct sunlight. It is one of the lightest covers we evaluated, making it easy to toss in the trunk when not in use.
However, the thin material and simple drawstring closure mean it may not stay tight in windy conditions, and it offers minimal impact protection. If you park indoors or in a garage, this cover can extend the life of your spare. For outdoor parking or off-road use, we recommend spending more on a durable option. Skip this if you need long-term UV resistance.
- Universal fit with adjustable drawstring
- PVC backing for moisture protection
- Lightweight and easy to store
Pros: Very affordable; Works with plenty of tire sizes
Cons: Thin material; may not last long in harsh sun; Drawstring can loosen over time
7. Smittybilt 49651 Spare Tire Cover: Off-Road Ready
We evaluated the Smittybilt 49651 as a dedicated off-road cover. The heavy-duty vinyl and stitched seams are designed to withstand brush and minor impacts, and it fits oversized tires commonly found on lifted Jeeps and trucks. Owner feedback from off-road forums indicates it holds up well on the trail, though some noted it can be challenging to stretch over large tires.
However, this cover lacks UV inhibitors, so it may fade or crack after prolonged sun exposure. It also has a very tight fit that can be frustrating to install, especially in cold weather. If you primarily drive off-road and park in a garage, this is a solid choice. For daily sun exposure, look for a cover with UV protection. Skip this if you want an easy on/off experience.
- Heavy-duty vinyl resists abrasion from brush
- Stitched seams for added strength
- Designed for lifted off-road vehicles
Pros: Tough material for trail use; Fits very large tires
Cons: Difficult to install due to tight fit; No UV protection coating; prone to fading
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I measure my spare tire for a cover?
To measure your spare tire, use a tape measure to find the overall diameter (from top to bottom) and the width (sidewall to sidewall). Most covers list compatible tire sizes in inches. For universal covers, compare your measurements to the manufacturer’s range. A snug fit is best to prevent flapping and moisture ingress.
Are spare tire covers waterproof?
Most spare tire covers are water-resistant rather than fully waterproof. Materials like PVC-coated polyester or vinyl repel rain, but prolonged exposure or high-pressure washing can allow moisture through. For full waterproofing, look for covers with sealed seams or a rubberized backing. However, no cover is completely waterproof over time.
Will a spare tire cover damage my tire?
A properly fitted cover should not damage your tire. However, a cover that is too tight can cause abrasion, while a loose cover can trap moisture and dirt, leading to rot or rust. Choose a cover with a soft lining (fleece or felt) to prevent scratches on the wheel. Always ensure the cover is dry before installation.
How long do spare tire covers last?
The lifespan depends on material and exposure. Premium covers with UV-resistant fabric can last 3-5 years, while budget covers may show wear after 1-2 years. Factors like direct sunlight, extreme temperatures, and road debris affect durability. Regular cleaning and storage when not in use can extend life.
Can I use a spare tire cover on a mounted spare?
Yes, most spare tire covers are designed for mounted spares. Ensure the cover fits the tire size and clears any mounting hardware like brackets or hinges. Some covers have cutouts for backup cameras or license plates. Always check compatibility with your vehicle’s spare tire carrier.
Our Verdict
After researching and comparing the top spare tire covers, our top pick is the Covercraft UVS100 Custom Fit Spare Tire Cover for its superior UV protection, durable construction, and tailored fit. For a budget-friendly alternative, the Leader Accessories Black Heavy Duty Spare Tire Cover offers solid value for basic protection. Choose based on your climate, tire size, and usage frequency.
More Tires Guides
Video Guide
Video: Related tutorial from YouTube