Expanding your vehicle’s cargo capacity is essential for road trips, outdoor adventures, or simply managing extra gear. Roof rack luggage carriers provide a secure and convenient solution, transforming your car’s rooftop into valuable storage space.
In our comprehensive guide, we researched and evaluated a variety of roof rack luggage carriers, analyzing manufacturer specifications, published industry standards for safety and aerodynamics, and aggregated owner feedback. Our aim is to help you navigate the options and choose the best carrier that aligns with your needs for capacity, durability, security, and ease of use.
| Photo | Product | Score | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
 |
Thule Force XT L Rooftop Cargo Box Top Pick: Premium Hard Shell 16 cu ft (450 L) capacity, Dual-Side opening |
9.1 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
Yakima SkyBox 16 Carbonite Cargo Box Runner-Up: Adaptable Hard Shell 16 cu ft (450 L) capacity, Carbonite finish |
8.7 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
Rightline Gear Sport 3 Car Top Carrier Best Waterproof Soft Carrier 18 cu ft capacity, 100% waterproof |
8.4 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
SportRack Vista XL Cargo Box Best Value Hard Shell 18 cu ft capacity, Passenger side opening |
8.0 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
ROLA V-Tex Apex Roof Top Cargo Basket All-around Open Basket 52"L x 38"W x 6"H, Steel construction |
7.8 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
CURT 18115 Roof Mounted Cargo Basket Budget-Friendly Basket 41.5" x 37" x 4" internal dimensions, Steel |
7.4 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
Keeper 07203-1 Waterproof Roof Top Cargo Bag Economical Soft Bag 15 cu ft capacity, Soft-sided |
7.2 | 🛒 Check Price |
1. Thule Force XT L Rooftop Cargo Box: Top Pick: Premium Hard Shell
Based on our evaluation, the Thule Force XT L offers a top-tier combination of capacity, security, and user convenience. Its AeroSkin design is engineered to minimize aerodynamic drag, which, according to manufacturer specifications and owner feedback, can result in less wind noise and potentially better fuel economy compared to less streamlined options. The PowerClick mounting system is consistently praised for its intuitive and secure attachment process, ensuring the box is firmly seated on various crossbar types.
However, the primary limitation of this premium hard shell carrier is its substantial size and corresponding storage requirement when not mounted on a vehicle. Owners often note that finding a suitable storage space in a garage or shed can be a challenge. Therefore, individuals with limited storage space at home or those who only require occasional, temporary extra cargo capacity might find this option less practical and could consider a more compact or collapsible soft carrier instead.
- AeroSkin lid texture reduces drag and noise, contributing to fuel efficiency.
- PowerClick quick-mount system for fast, secure attachment to roof racks.
- SlideLock system with separate locking and opening functions for enhanced security.
Pros: Exceptional weather resistance and cargo protection.; Tool-free installation and dual-side access streamline loading and unloading.; Solid construction provides superior security for contents.
Cons: Significant investment compared to other carrier types.; Bulky dimensions can make storage challenging when not in use.
2. Yakima SkyBox 16 Carbonite Cargo Box: Runner-Up: Multi-purpose Hard Shell
In our comparison, the Yakima SkyBox 16 Carbonite stands out for its sturdy construction and thoughtful design features. The internal lid stiffeners are a notable detail, contributing to a more solid feel and smoother operation, which is often appreciated in owner reviews. Its 16 cubic feet of storage is generous, accommodating a variety of gear including longer items, making it a flexible choice for different types of trips.
A point to consider is the weight and bulk of the unit, which based on owner feedback, can make initial installation or removal a two-person job for safety and ease. While the mounting system is tool-free and straightforward, maneuvering the box itself requires some effort. Individuals who frequently need to remove and re-install their cargo box alone, or those prioritizing the lightest possible option for minimal impact on vehicle dynamics, might find this model less ideal and could explore lighter, potentially smaller, or soft-sided alternatives.
- Internal lid stiffeners add rigidity and make opening and closing smoother.
- SuperLatch security ensures the lid is secure to the base and your gear is safe.
- Tool-free, quick-release mounting hardware fits most crossbar shapes.
Pros: Excellent build quality and a low-profile, modern carbonite finish.; Ample storage capacity suitable for skis and snowboards up to 170cm.; Dual-side opening and easy to use mounting system enhance convenience.
Cons: Can be heavy and awkward for a single person to mount.; The carbonite finish, while attractive, can show scratches over time.
3. Rightline Gear Sport 3 Car Top Carrier: Best Waterproof Soft Carrier
Our evaluation of the Rightline Gear Sport 3 Car Top Carrier highlights its superior waterproofing, a critical feature for any soft-sided carrier. The combination of its zipper-flap and hook-and-loop closure system, alongside welded seams, is consistently effective in keeping contents dry, a point frequently affirmed in owner feedback. Its adaptability, allowing attachment to vehicles with or without existing roof racks, makes it an excellent solution for many users.
However, the inherent nature of a soft-sided carrier means it offers less security against theft compared to a hard shell box. While it includes durable straps for attachment, the fabric construction can be breached with determined effort. Therefore, individuals who frequently transport high-value items or park their vehicle in unsecured locations for extended periods might find the security features of this carrier insufficient and should consider a rigid cargo box for confidence.
- Utilizes a zipper-flap and hook-and-loop closure for strong waterproofing.
- Attaches to vehicles with or without a roof rack using included straps.
- Folds down compactly for easy storage when not in use.
Pros: Exceptional waterproofing, protecting contents in all weather conditions.; Highly adaptable attachment options for a variety of vehicles.; Collapsible design allows for minimal storage footprint.
Cons: Security is less solid than hard shell carriers.; Can be less aerodynamic when fully packed, potentially impacting fuel economy.
4. SportRack Vista XL Cargo Box: Best Value Hard Shell
In our research, the SportRack Vista XL emerges as a strong contender for those seeking a hard shell cargo box without the premium price tag. Its 18 cubic feet of storage is generous, making it suitable for larger families or longer trips. The quick-release mounting system is straightforward, and owner feedback generally indicates a simple installation process on various factory and aftermarket crossbars.
A notable limitation of the Vista XL is its single-side opening, which is exclusively on the passenger side. While this is a common design choice for value-oriented boxes, it can be less convenient than dual-side opening models, particularly when accessing gear from different angles or in tight parking situations. Users who frequently need quick and flexible access to their cargo, or those who prefer the convenience of dual access, might find this design constraint cumbersome and should consider investing in a carrier with multi-directional access.
- Quick-release mounting system for easy attachment to most roof racks.
- Impact-resistant ABS construction offers good protection for gear.
- Large 18 cubic feet of storage provides ample space for family trips.
Pros: Offers excellent cargo capacity for its value segment.; Simple and relatively quick installation process.; Provides a good balance of weather protection and security for the price.
Cons: Only opens from one side, which can be inconvenient.; Material can feel less sturdy than premium hard shells.
5. ROLA V-Tex Apex Roof Top Cargo Basket: All-around Open Basket
Our evaluation of the ROLA V-Tex Apex Roof Top Cargo Basket highlights its strength as a multi-purpose option for carrying diverse cargo. Its open design is particularly advantageous for irregularly shaped items like camping gear, spare tires, or lumber that wouldn’t fit into a traditional cargo box. The heavy-duty steel construction with a powder-coat finish is designed for durability and resistance against the elements, a feature consistently praised in owner reviews for its ruggedness.
The main drawback of an open cargo basket like the V-Tex Apex is the lack of inherent weather protection or security for your belongings. Any items placed in the basket will be exposed to rain, road grime, and sun, necessitating the use of additional waterproof bags, tarps, or cargo nets, which are not included. Therefore, individuals primarily transporting sensitive electronics, clothing, or other items that require full protection from the elements and theft should be aware of these additional requirements and might find a fully enclosed hard shell or waterproof soft carrier a more suitable primary solution.
- Heavy-duty steel construction with a durable powder-coat finish for corrosion resistance.
- Universal mounting hardware fits most round, square, and aerodynamic crossbars.
- Low-profile design minimizes wind resistance and maintains vehicle aesthetics.
Pros: Highly flexible for irregularly shaped items that don't fit in boxes.; Durable steel construction provides excellent longevity.; Easy to clean and maintain after off-road adventures.
Cons: Requires additional waterproof bags or netting for cargo protection.; Adds significant wind noise, especially at higher speeds.
6. CURT 18115 Roof Mounted Cargo Basket: Budget-Friendly Basket
In our comparison, the CURT 18115 Roof Mounted Cargo Basket offers an accessible entry point into roof rack cargo solutions. Its tubular steel construction is designed for strength, allowing it to handle substantial loads, which is a key advantage for an open basket. The inclusion of a wind fairing is a thoughtful addition, aiming to mitigate some of the common wind noise issues associated with baskets, a feature often noted in aggregated owner feedback.
However, the assembly of this cargo basket, while not overly complex, can be more time-consuming than plug-and-play options, requiring the attachment of multiple pieces. Owners sometimes report that fitting all components together precisely can take patience. Individuals who prioritize immediate, minimal-fuss installation or those who are not comfortable with basic assembly tasks might find this aspect a minor inconvenience. For these users, pre-assembled basket options or simpler soft carriers might offer a more streamlined experience out of the box.
- Durable tubular steel construction with a durable black powder coat finish.
- Designed to mount to most roof rack crossbars with universal hardware.
- Includes a wind fairing to help reduce wind noise and drag.
Pros: Cost-effective solution for increasing cargo capacity.; Durable steel frame is capable of carrying heavy, bulky items.; Relatively straightforward assembly and installation process.
Cons: Assembly can be time-consuming due to multiple parts.; The included wind fairing may not eliminate all wind noise.
7. Keeper 07203-1 Waterproof Roof Top Cargo Bag: Economical Soft Bag
Based on our research, the Keeper 07203-1 Waterproof Roof Top Cargo Bag presents an economical solution for adding temporary cargo capacity. Its soft-sided, collapsible design is a significant advantage for users with limited storage space, allowing it to be stowed away easily when not needed. The waterproof material and included straps offer a basic level of protection against the elements and secure attachment to existing roof racks, as noted in owner experiences.
A primary limitation of this cargo bag is its lack of rigidity. When not fully packed, it can sag or shift, potentially impacting aerodynamics and making it more challenging to load and secure items evenly. This can also lead to increased wind noise and less stable performance compared to rigid carriers. Individuals who frequently travel with varied loads, or who prefer a more structured and stable cargo solution, might find the flexible nature of this bag less ideal and should consider a more rigid soft carrier or a hard shell box for improved stability and ease of packing.
- Constructed from waterproof material with a soft-grip bottom to protect vehicle finish.
- Folds flat for compact storage when not in use, saving space.
- Attaches to roof racks with included heavy-duty straps and buckles.
Pros: Highly affordable option for occasional extra cargo space.; Compact storage when empty, ideal for limited storage areas.; Provides good water resistance for basic weather protection.
Cons: Lacks rigidity, which can make loading and securing challenging.; Durability is not comparable to hard shell carriers for long-term heavy use.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the difference between a cargo box, a cargo bag, and a cargo basket?
Cargo boxes are rigid, hard shell containers offering excellent weather protection and security. Cargo bags are soft-sided, flexible, waterproof, and collapsible for easy storage, often more affordable. Cargo baskets are open platforms, ideal for oddly shaped items, but require additional waterproofing and securing with nets or straps.
Will a roof rack luggage carrier affect my vehicle's fuel economy?
Yes, any item mounted on your roof will increase aerodynamic drag, which can reduce your vehicle’s fuel economy. Hard shell boxes are often designed with aerodynamics in mind to minimize this impact, while soft bags and open baskets can have a more pronounced effect, especially if not packed efficiently.
How do I ensure my roof rack luggage carrier is secure?
Always follow the manufacturer’s installation instructions precisely. Ensure all mounting hardware is tightened correctly and regularly check for looseness, especially after initial installation and during long trips. For cargo bags and baskets, use sturdy straps or cargo nets to secure contents tightly to prevent shifting.
Can I install a roof rack luggage carrier on any car?
Most roof rack luggage carriers require an existing roof rack system (crossbars and side rails). Some soft cargo bags can be attached directly to vehicles without a roof rack using door frame straps, but this is less common for hard boxes or baskets. Always verify compatibility with your vehicle and existing rack system before purchase.
What is the weight limit for roof rack luggage carriers?
The weight limit is determined by the lowest capacity of three components: your vehicle’s roof weight limit, your roof rack’s weight limit, and the carrier’s weight limit. Always consult your vehicle owner’s manual and the specifications for your roof rack and carrier to avoid overloading, which can be dangerous.
Our Verdict
After thorough research and comparison, the Thule Force XT L Rooftop Cargo Box stands out as our top pick for its superior blend of capacity, security, aerodynamics, and easy to use features. For a highly adaptable and well-constructed alternative, the Yakima SkyBox 16 Carbonite Cargo Box is our runner-up, offering excellent performance for a variety of cargo needs.
More Exterior Protection Guides
Video Guide
Video: Related tutorial from YouTube