Whether you are planning a road trip or need extra cargo space for daily errands, a luggage attachment can transform your car’s capacity. We researched and compared the most popular options on the market, evaluating manufacturer specifications, safety standards, and aggregated owner feedback. This guide covers roof boxes, cargo bags, hitch carriers, trunk organizers, and more to help you choose the right solution for your vehicle and needs.
| Photo | Product | Score | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
|
🚗
|
Thule Motion XT L Roof Box Top Pick: Best Overall Roof Box Capacity: 16 cu ft, Weight: 44 lbs, Fits cars with roof rails |
9.2 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Yakima GrandTour 16 Roof Box Runner Up: Premium Alternative Capacity: 16 cu ft, Weight: 48 lbs, Fits most vehicles with crossbars |
8.8 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Rightline Gear 100C Cargo Bag Best Value Soft Roof Carrier Capacity: 15 cu ft, Weight: 8 lbs, Fits vehicles with or without roof racks |
8.1 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Curt 18103 Class 3 Trailer Hitch Cargo Carrier Best Hitch-Mounted Carrier Capacity: 500 lbs, Weight: 32 lbs, Fits 2-inch receiver hitch |
8.4 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Smittybilt 2783 Cargo Bag Best for SUVs and Jeeps Capacity: 12 cu ft, Weight: 5 lbs, Fits roof racks with crossbars |
7.8 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
TrunkMate Car Trunk Organizer Best Interior Trunk Organizer Capacity: 45L, Weight: 2 lbs, Fits most car trunks |
7.3 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
AA Products Universal Car Roof Top Cargo Carrier Bag Budget Pick Capacity: 12 cu ft, Weight: 4 lbs, Fits cars with or without roof racks |
7.0 | 🛒 Check Price |
1. Thule Motion XT L Roof Box: Top Pick: Best Overall Roof Box
The Thule Motion XT L is a premium roof box that excels in aerodynamic performance and ease of use. In our evaluation, we found its dual-side opening and PowerClick quick-mount system make installation straightforward. Owner feedback consistently praises its weatherproofing and security features. However, the high cost and need for existing roof rails may deter some buyers.
This is an excellent choice for frequent travelers who prioritize low noise and secure storage. Skip it if you have a tight budget or a vehicle without roof rails, as the additional crossbar investment can be significant.
- Aerodynamic design reduces wind noise and drag, improving fuel efficiency.
- Dual-side opening with quick-mount system for easy loading and unloading.
- Central locking system with keys for security; meets TUV safety standards.
Pros: Excellent build quality and weather sealing.; Very low wind noise compared to competitors.
Cons: High price point may not suit budget shoppers.; Requires roof rails or crossbars (sold separately).
2. Yakima GrandTour 16 Roof Box: Runner Up: Premium Alternative
The Yakima GrandTour 16 offers a solid build and thoughtful features like built-in lid struts and tie-down loops. Our research shows it is slightly heavier than the Thule but still performs well in wind tunnel tests. Owner feedback indicates high satisfaction with durability and security. The main drawback is the interior shape, which may not accommodate bulky items as easily as some other boxes.
This is a great option for those who value a strong warranty and solid construction. It is less ideal if you need to maximize every cubic inch of space or want the lightest possible box.
- Low-profile low-profile shape with built-in lid struts for one-handed operation.
- SKS locking system secures box to crossbars and lid.
- Interior tie-down loops keep cargo from shifting.
Pros: Very sturdy construction with a 10-year warranty.; Smooth opening mechanism and easy mounting.
Cons: Heavier than some competitors, affecting fuel economy slightly.; Interior space is less efficiently shaped than Thule Motion XT.
3. Rightline Gear 100C Cargo Bag: Best Value Soft Roof Carrier
The Rightline Gear 100C is a popular soft cargo bag for those who need occasional extra space without a permanent roof box. Based on owner feedback, it is easy to install and remove, and the waterproof material holds up well in rain. However, in our evaluation, we noted that the straps can loosen over long drives, requiring periodic checks. Also, it is not lockable, so it is best for short stops.
This is a solid choice for budget-conscious users or those who only need extra space occasionally. Skip it if you travel frequently at highway speeds or need theft-resistant storage.
- Waterproof 600D PVC-coated polyester with welded seams.
- Includes 6 heavy-duty straps and door anchor loops for secure fit.
- Reflective strips for nighttime visibility and safety.
Pros: Very affordable compared to hard-shell roof boxes.; Easy to store when not in use; folds flat.
Cons: Less aerodynamic; may cause wind noise and drag.; Not as secure against theft as a locked hard shell.
4. Curt 18103 Class 3 Trailer Hitch Cargo Carrier: Best Hitch-Mounted Carrier
The Curt 18103 is a heavy-duty hitch cargo carrier that excels in capacity and durability. Our research indicates it is built to last, with a sturdy steel frame and a folding mechanism that is convenient for accessing the trunk. Owner reviews highlight its stability on the road. The main downsides are the need for a hitch and the potential obstruction of rear visibility and sensors.
This is perfect for those with a hitch receiver who need to haul heavy or bulky items. It is less suitable for small cars without a hitch or for drivers who rely heavily on rear cameras.
- Heavy-duty steel construction with black powder coat finish.
- Folding design for easy access to rear hatch without removing carrier.
- Includes anti-rattle bolt and tie-down hooks.
Pros: Very high weight capacity; can carry coolers, bikes, or luggage.; Durable and rust-resistant for long-term use.
Cons: Requires a trailer hitch (not included).; Blocks rear view and may affect parking sensor operation.
5. Smittybilt 2783 Cargo Bag: Best for SUVs and Jeeps
The Smittybilt 2783 is a no-frills cargo bag designed for off-road enthusiasts. Based on owner feedback, it holds up well in dusty and muddy conditions. However, in our evaluation, we found that the lack of a rigid structure means it can deform and create wind noise. The zipper is also a common complaint. It is best used for soft items like clothing and sleeping bags.
This is a good budget option for Jeep and SUV owners who do not drive at highway speeds often. Skip it if you need a stable, aerodynamic carrier for long road trips.
- Heavy-duty 600 denier nylon with PVC coating.
- Adjustable straps with quick-release buckles.
- Zip closure with hook-and-loop weather flap.
Pros: Very rugged material suited for off-road use.; Low cost and lightweight.
Cons: No internal frame; can sag and flap at high speeds.; Zipper can be difficult to operate with cold hands.
6. TrunkMate Car Trunk Organizer: Best Interior Trunk Organizer
The TrunkMate Car Trunk Organizer is a simple solution for keeping smaller items tidy in your trunk. Our research shows it is popular among daily drivers who need to separate groceries or sports gear. The non-slip base and dividers work well for light loads. However, it is not a replacement for a roof box or hitch carrier, as it cannot hold large suitcases or heavy items securely.
This is best for those who want to organize their trunk for everyday use. Skip it if you need to transport bulky luggage or want to free up passenger space.
- Collapsible design with rigid dividers to prevent items from shifting.
- Non-slip base and adjustable straps to secure in trunk.
- Multiple compartments for groceries, tools, or luggage.
Pros: Very affordable and easy to store when not in use.; Helps keep trunk organized and prevents items from rolling.
Cons: Not weatherproof; not suitable for liquids or messy items.; Limited capacity; not for large luggage.
7. AA Products Universal Car Roof Top Cargo Carrier Bag: Budget Pick
The AA Products cargo bag is the most affordable option in our guide. Based on owner feedback, it works for short trips with light loads but has durability concerns. In our evaluation, we noted that the material is less durable than the Rightline Gear bag, and the straps can slip. It is best used for soft, lightweight items and at moderate speeds.
This is a last-resort option for those on a very tight budget or for emergency use. Skip it if you plan to use it regularly or carry heavy items, as the risk of damage or detachment is higher.
- Waterproof 420D nylon fabric with taped seams.
- Includes 4 straps with buckle and door hook anchors.
- Reflective stripes for safety at night.
Pros: Very low price point.; Lightweight and easy to store.
Cons: Thin material prone to tearing if overloaded.; Straps may loosen; requires frequent adjustment.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the safest way to attach luggage to my car?
The safest method is to use a hard-shell roof box or a hitch-mounted carrier that meets safety standards like TUV or SAE. Always follow the manufacturer’s installation instructions, secure all straps, and check tightness periodically. Avoid overloading, and ensure the attachment does not block lights or license plates.
Can I use a roof cargo bag on a car without roof rails?
Yes, many cargo bags come with door anchor loops that fit into the door frames. However, this method is less secure than using roof rails. We recommend checking the bag’s weight limit and driving at moderate speeds. For frequent use, consider installing crossbars or a roof box.
Will a roof box affect my car's fuel economy?
Yes, any roof attachment increases aerodynamic drag, reducing fuel economy. Hard-shell boxes have less impact than soft bags, but you can expect a 10-20% drop in highway mpg. Removing the box when not in use helps restore efficiency.
How much weight can a hitch cargo carrier hold?
Most hitch carriers have a capacity between 300-500 lbs, but you must also consider your vehicle’s tongue weight rating (usually 10-15% of towing capacity). Always check your owner’s manual and do not exceed both limits.
Are trunk organizers worth it for luggage?
Trunk organizers are great for small items and daily use, but they are not designed for large luggage. If you need to carry multiple suitcases or bulky gear, a roof box or hitch carrier is more practical.
Our Verdict
After researching and comparing, our top pick is the Thule Motion XT L for its superior aerodynamics, ease of use, and security. The Yakima GrandTour 16 is a close runner-up with excellent build quality. For budget-conscious buyers, the Rightline Gear 100C offers the best value among soft carriers.
More Car Accessories Guides
Video Guide
Video: Related tutorial from YouTube