Finding the right containment solution for a large dog in a vehicle requires balancing crash safety with fitment constraints. We researched manufacturer specifications, independent safety testing, and aggregated owner feedback to evaluate which crates truly protect pets during travel.
Our evaluation focuses on structural integrity, ease of loading into a backseat, and ventilation. We compared industry standards to identify options that offer security without compromising comfort for your animal.
| Photo | Product | Score | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
 |
Gunner Kennels G1 Intermediate Top Overall Pick Double wall rotomolded polyethylene |
9.2 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
Impact Dog Crate Best Heavy Duty Welded aluminum alloy frame |
8.8 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
Petmate Vari Kennel Ultra Best Plastic Value Heavy duty plastic shell |
8.5 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
Pet Gear Roadster Best Soft Sided Steel frame with mesh windows |
8.1 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
MidWest iCrate Best Wire Option Secure slide bolt latches |
7.8 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Vivaglory Dog Crate Good Budget Soft 600D Oxford fabric |
7.4 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
PetFusion Portable Dog Crate Honorable Mention Non toxic materials |
7.2 | 🛒 Check Price |
1. Gunner Kennels G1 Intermediate: Top Overall Pick
In our evaluation of crash evaluated crates, the Gunner G1 stands out due to its double wall rotomolded construction and CPS certification. We compared its specifications to other plastic models and found the reinforced steel door latches and heavy duty barrel locks provide superior retention during impact. The raised floor design keeps pets dry and allows for debris to fall through, which owners appreciate for long road trips.
However, the weight of this unit is a significant consideration. Based on owner feedback, lifting this crate into a backseat can be difficult for a single person. If you frequently need to remove the crate from your vehicle, the heavy build might be a hassle. This model is best suited for owners who prioritize maximum safety over portability.
- Certified crash protection for pets
- Integrated tie down strapping points
- Non porous floor for easy cleaning
Pros: High strength build quality; Excellent ventilation system
Cons: Heavy to move in and out of vehicle
2. Impact Dog Crate: Best Heavy Duty
We researched heavy duty options for dogs that claw or chew through standard plastic crates. The Impact Dog Crate features a welded aluminum alloy frame that resists destruction better than any wire or plastic alternative we evaluated. The folding design allows it to fit in a backseat when assembled, though it requires significant space. The included sliding door with multiple latches ensures even the most determined Houdini cannot escape.
While the build quality is exceptional, the value score reflects the premium nature of this product. It is a significant investment. Additionally, the aluminum frame can be noisy if your dog moves around a lot, creating rattling sounds against the car upholstery. We recommend this for owners of destructive dogs who need containment that standard crates cannot provide.
- Escape proof design for anxious dogs
- High strength aluminum construction
- Folding configuration for storage
Pros: Extremely durable and escape resistant; Good air circulation
Cons: Higher cost relative to plastic models
3. Petmate Vari Kennel Ultra: Best Plastic Value
The Petmate Vari Kennel Ultra is a staple in the industry. We compared its structural specs to other plastic carriers and found it offers a solid shell that protects pets from the elements. The wing nut assembly makes it easy to take apart for cleaning or storage, which is a plus for backseat use where space is at a premium. Its design meets airline regulations, making it a adaptable choice for travelers.
Our analysis of safety features indicates it lacks the integrated steel reinforcement of higher end crash evaluated models. While durable in a crash, it does not have specific CPS certification. Owners should also note that the plastic can become brittle in extreme cold over time. This is a solid choice for everyday travel but may not offer the highest level of impact protection.
- Meets most airline travel requirements
- Adjustable ventilation on four sides
- Easy to assemble with wing nuts
Pros: Strong and durable plastic shell; Affordable and widely available
Cons: Limited visibility compared to wire crates
4. Pet Gear Roadster: Best Soft Sided
For owners who need a crate that is easy to move, we evaluated the Pet Gear Roadster. It features a steel frame that provides more stability than typical soft crates, yet it remains lightweight. The mesh windows offer good ventilation and visibility for your pet, reducing anxiety during travel. We found the water resistant fabric holds up well against dirt and drool based on owner feedback.
It is critical to note that soft crates offer minimal crash protection compared to hard plastic or aluminum options. In our evaluation of safety standards, this model provides containment but not impact resistance. It is strictly for calm, well behaved dogs. If your pet has separation anxiety or tends to chew, the mesh sides will likely be destroyed quickly.
- Water resistant fabric
- Folds flat for storage
- Multiple pockets for storage
Pros: Lightweight and easy to transport; Simple to set up and fold down
Cons: Not suitable for dogs that chew or scratch
5. MidWest iCrate: Best Wire Option
The MidWest iCrate is a popular wire option that we researched for its ventilation and visibility. Dogs often feel less claustrophobic in wire crates due to the open view. The double door design makes loading a large dog into a backseat easier, as you can orient the crate to suit the vehicle layout. The divider panel is a useful feature for growing puppies.
In our comparison of safety features, wire crates performed the worst in crash scenarios. The metal can bend or collapse, potentially injuring the pet. Also, the coating can scratch off, leading to rust. We only recommend this crate for restrained, calm dogs where crash safety is not the primary concern, or for use with a crash evaluated crate cover.
- Double door design for access
- Pan included for mess containment
- Fold and carry configuration
Pros: Excellent visibility and airflow; Very economical option
Cons: Metal can rust over time; No crash protection
6. Vivaglory Dog Crate: Good Budget Soft
We analyzed the Vivaglory crate as a budget friendly soft option. It comes with a fleece bed, which adds comfort for the pet during car rides. The 600D Oxford fabric is standard for this price point. The multiple entry points help when placing the crate in a tight backseat space. Owners report that the pockets are handy for storing leashes and treats.
However, our evaluation of durability highlights weak points in the zippers and stitching. Large dogs that lean against the walls may stretch the fabric significantly. Like other soft crates, it offers zero protection in a collision. This is a temporary containment solution best suited for small cars or very calm, older dogs that do not exert pressure on the walls.
- Large side pockets for accessories
- Fleece bed included
- Three doors for easy access
Pros: Includes comfortable bedding; Lightweight and portable
Cons: Zippers are not heavy duty
7. PetFusion Portable Dog Crate: Honorable Mention
The PetFusion Portable crate offers a modern look that differs from the utilitarian style of traditional crates. We researched its materials and found they are non toxic and easy to wipe down, which is beneficial for keeping the car interior clean. The four door design provides flexibility for positioning in the backseat.
Despite the appealing aesthetics, our comparison indicates it lacks the ruggedness needed for travel. The structure relies on plastic supports that can fail under stress from a large, active dog. It is not designed to withstand the force of a car accident. We suggest skipping this model if you need a crate for heavy duty travel or long distance safety.
- Modern aesthetic design
- Easy to clean surface
- Four doors for versatility
Pros: Stylish appearance; Simple to clean
Cons: Limited structural integrity
Frequently Asked Questions
Are soft sided crates safe for car travel?
Based on our evaluation of safety standards, soft sided crates generally do not offer crash protection. They are suitable for containment but will not protect your pet in a collision. Hard plastic or aluminum crates are significantly safer for travel.
How do I secure a dog crate in the backseat?
We recommend using straps specifically designed for pet travel or the vehicle seat belts threaded through the crate handles or around the base. Always check the manufacturer instructions to ensure you are using approved tie down points without compromising the crate structure.
What size crate fits in a car backseat?
Backseat dimensions vary by vehicle. We researched spec sheets and found that large crates often require the front seats to be moved forward. Measure your backseat width and length before purchasing to ensure the crate fits without obstructing the driver or passenger seats.
Do I need a crash evaluated crate?
While not legally required in all places, our research strongly suggests using a Center for Pet Safety certified crate. These models undergo rigorous testing to simulate crashes. Standard crates can collapse or fail upon impact, posing a risk to your pet and other passengers.
Can I use a wire crate in the car?
You can use a wire crate, but our analysis shows they offer the least protection in an accident. They can bend and collapse. If you must use a wire crate, ensure it is securely anchored and consider that metal shards could be dangerous in a crash.
Our Verdict
Our research identifies the Gunner Kennels G1 as the top pick for its unmatched safety ratings and durable build. For those needing a heavy duty escape proof option, the Impact Dog Crate is the runner up.
More Car Accessories Guides
Video Guide
Video: Related tutorial from YouTube