After researching dozens of cargo trays, comparing manufacturer specifications, and analyzing owner feedback, we selected the seven best options for protecting your trunk or cargo area. Our evaluation focuses on fit, material durability, spill containment, and ease of cleaning. Whether you need a custom-fit liner for a specific SUV or a universal mat for a sedan, this guide covers top choices from WeatherTech, Husky Liners, and more.
We did not perform hands-on lab testing, but we relied on published industry standards for material safety (e.g., VOC emissions), customer reviews from verified purchasers, and compatibility data from automaker specifications. Each product is scored based on performance, durability, value, ease of use, and safety. Be aware: no single tray fits every need, and some have limitations such as sliding on carpet or lacking raised edges.
| Photo | Product | Score | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
|
🚗
|
WeatherTech Cargo Liner Best Overall Custom-molded for specific vehicle models; raised lip; non-skid surface. |
9.2 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Husky Liners WeatherBeater Cargo Liner Runner Up Custom fit; dual-layer construction; raised edges. |
8.8 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Lasfit Custom Fit Cargo Liner Best Value TPE material; custom fit for select models; anti-slip backing. |
8.5 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Motor Trend Premium Cargo Mat Universal Pick Universal fit; trim-to-size design; heavy-duty rubber. |
8.1 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
BDK ProLiner Trunk Mat All-Weather Choice Universal fit; heavy-duty PVC; non-slip backing. |
7.8 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
OEDRO Cargo Liner Budget Pick Universal fit; TPE material; foldable design. |
7.5 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Maxliner Custom Fit Cargo Mat Heavy Duty Option Custom fit for select vehicles; heavy-duty rubber; deep channels. |
7.2 | 🛒 Check Price |
1. WeatherTech Cargo Liner: Best Overall
After comparing manufacturer specs and owner feedback, the WeatherTech Cargo Liner stands out for its precision fit and durable spill protection. The custom-molded design matches the exact contours of your trunk or cargo area, and the raised lip traps liquids effectively. In our evaluation, owners consistently praise its durability and non-slip surface, making it a top choice for daily use and outdoor gear transport.
However, this liner is not ideal for those who need flexible storage: it does not fold easily, and if you frequently use third-row seating, the coverage may be incomplete. Also, the premium price may not suit budget-conscious buyers. Skip this if you want a removable mat that can be rolled up for storage.
- Custom fit for hundreds of vehicle models ensures full coverage.
- Raised outer lip contains spills up to 1.5 inches deep.
- Made in USA from proprietary thermoplastic elastomer (TPE) with low VOC emissions.
Pros: Excellent spill containment and easy to clean with a hose.; Stays in place without sliding on carpet.
Cons: Higher cost compared to universal mats; may not fit vehicles with third-row seats in use.
2. Husky Liners WeatherBeater Cargo Liner: Runner Up
Our research shows the Husky Liners WeatherBeater is a strong contender, offering a custom fit with a slightly lower price point than the WeatherTech. Owner feedback highlights its excellent spill containment and easy cleaning. The dual-layer construction provides good traction for cargo, and the raised edges work well for containing dirt and water.
Where it falls short is long-term edge curling, especially in hot climates. Some owners noted that the liner does not lay completely flat after a few months. We recommend this for SUV owners who want a custom fit but are willing to accept a minor trade-off in long-term flatness. Skip if you need a very rigid tray that will never warp.
- Dual-layer design with a textured top surface for grip.
- Raised outer edge contains spills and debris.
- Form-fit to specific vehicle models, available for many trucks and SUVs.
Pros: Strong odor resistance and easy to clean.; Good value for a custom-fit liner.
Cons: May be slightly thinner than WeatherTech; some users report curling at edges over time.
3. Lasfit Custom Fit Cargo Liner: Best Value
For budget-conscious buyers, the Lasfit Custom Fit Cargo Liner offers impressive value. In our evaluation, it provides a good custom fit for many popular SUVs and crossovers at a lower cost. Owners appreciate the lack of odor and the easy installation. The TPE material is flexible yet durable enough for everyday spills and dirt.
However, the liner is thinner than premium options, which may lead to less protection against punctures from sharp objects. Also, vehicle compatibility is limited: if your car is not in their catalog, you are out of luck. We suggest this for owners of supported models who want a reliable, low-cost liner and do not need heavy-duty protection.
- Made from non-toxic, odorless TPE material.
- Custom-molded for specific vehicles with a raised lip.
- Anti-slip nibs on the underside keep it in place.
Pros: Very affordable for a custom-fit liner.; No strong chemical smell out of the box.
Cons: Limited vehicle coverage; not as many models as WeatherTech.; Thinner material may not hold heavy loads as well.
4. Motor Trend Premium Cargo Mat: Universal Pick
If you need a cargo tray that works across multiple vehicles, the Motor Trend Premium Cargo Mat is a solid universal option. Based on owner feedback, the trim-to-size design allows for a decent custom fit, though it cannot match the precision of a molded liner. The heavy-duty rubber provides good durability and spill resistance.
On the downside, the mat may slide on some carpeted surfaces, and the initial rubber smell can be off-putting. It also does not have a very high lip, so large spills might overflow. We recommend this for those who frequently switch vehicles or want an inexpensive solution for a rarely used trunk. Skip if you need a perfect fit or maximum spill containment.
- Can be trimmed to fit most cargo areas with scissors.
- Heavy-duty rubber construction with a textured surface.
- Raised edges help contain spills.
Pros: Multi-purpose fit for many vehicles, including hatchbacks and wagons.; Good grip and easy to clean.
Cons: Does not cover every contour; may leave gaps.; Rubber odor may be strong initially.
5. BDK ProLiner Trunk Mat: All-Weather Choice
The BDK ProLiner Trunk Mat is a budget-friendly universal option that works well for light use. In our research, owners appreciate its low cost and ease of cleaning. The PVC material is waterproof and can handle minor spills, but it lacks the robustness of premium materials.
However, this mat is not designed for heavy-duty use. It may slide around on carpet, and the lack of raised edges means liquids can run off onto the trunk floor. Also, in very cold weather, the PVC can become stiff and crack. We suggest this for basic protection in a car that rarely carries messy items. Skip if you need a secure fit or plan to transport wet gear.
- Made from heavy-duty PVC material that resists water and stains.
- Non-slip backing helps keep it in place.
- Can be trimmed to fit various trunk shapes.
Pros: Very affordable and widely available.; Easy to wipe clean with a damp cloth.
Cons: Not as durable as TPE or rubber; may crack in extreme cold.; Does not have raised edges for spill containment.
6. OEDRO Cargo Liner: Budget Pick
The OEDRO Cargo Liner is the most budget-friendly option in our guide. It is made from TPE, which is better than PVC, but the thin construction limits its protective ability. Owner feedback indicates it works fine for light items like groceries but may not hold up to heavy gear or sharp edges.
Its foldability is a plus for those who need to remove the tray frequently, but the lack of a raised lip means any liquid spill will likely run off the mat. Also, the fit is loose and may shift during driving. We recommend this only for occasional use in a vehicle that already has carpet protection. Skip if you need a permanent, sturdy liner.
- Foldable TPE material allows easy storage when not in use.
- Universal design fits most sedans and hatchbacks with trimming.
- Non-slip surface keeps cargo from sliding.
Pros: Very inexpensive and lightweight.; Foldable for convenient storage.
Cons: Thin material may not withstand heavy loads or sharp objects.; Does not have a raised lip; spills can escape.
7. Maxliner Custom Fit Cargo Mat: Heavy Duty Option
The Maxliner Custom Fit Cargo Mat is designed for heavy-duty use, with deep channels that handle mud, snow, and water effectively. In our evaluation, it offers good protection for work trucks or off-road vehicles. Owners like its rugged construction and ability to contain messy loads.
However, its weight and bulk make it inconvenient to remove for cleaning. Also, the vehicle fitment list is narrow, so many owners may not find a model for their car. The rubber can also have a strong odor initially. We suggest this for owners of compatible trucks or SUVs who regularly haul dirty or wet items. Skip if you need a lightweight, easy-to-handle liner.
- Deep channels direct water and debris away from cargo.
- Custom fit for a range of trucks and SUVs.
- Heavy-duty rubber construction resists wear.
Pros: Good for containing mud and snowmelt.; Durable rubber material.
Cons: Limited vehicle compatibility; not available for many models.; Heavy and bulky; difficult to remove and clean.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I choose between a custom-fit and a universal cargo tray?
Custom-fit trays are molded to your vehicle’s exact cargo floor contours, offering maximum coverage and spill protection. Universal trays are more affordable and can be trimmed to fit, but they may leave gaps and slide around. If you want a permanent, secure solution, choose custom-fit. For occasional use or multiple vehicles, a universal mat may suffice.
What materials are best for a cargo tray?
The most common materials are TPE (thermoplastic elastomer) and rubber. TPE is lightweight, flexible, and odorless, making it a popular choice. Rubber is heavier and more durable but may have a strong initial smell. PVC is also used in budget mats but is less durable and can crack in cold weather. We recommend TPE for a balance of performance and value.
Can I use a cargo tray with the third-row seats in use?
Many custom-fit cargo trays are designed for the cargo area behind the third row. If you need to use the third row, look for a tray that covers only the area behind the seats or one that can be folded. Some trays are not compatible with third-row seating, so check the product specifications before buying.
How do I clean and maintain my cargo tray?
Most cargo trays can be cleaned with mild soap and water. For heavy dirt, use a hose or pressure washer. Avoid harsh chemicals that may damage the material. Some trays can be removed and shaken out. Regular cleaning prevents odors and maintains grip.
Will a cargo tray fit my vehicle if it has a subwoofer or storage compartments?
Custom-fit trays are designed to accommodate factory features like spare tire humps and storage bins. However, if you have aftermarket subwoofers or non-standard modifications, the tray may not fit properly. Measure your cargo area and check the product’s compatibility notes before purchasing.
Our Verdict
After comparing specifications and owner feedback, the WeatherTech Cargo Liner is our top pick for its precise custom fit, excellent spill containment, and durable TPE construction. It is best for those who want maximum protection and are willing to invest in a premium product. For a more budget-friendly custom option, the Husky Liners WeatherBeater is our runner up, offering similar features at a lower price point with a slight compromise in long-term flatness.
More Car Accessories Guides
Video Guide
Video: Related tutorial from YouTube