After researching manufacturer specifications, industry safety standards, and aggregated owner feedback, we evaluated the best cargo carriers for trucks. Our comparison covers hitch-mounted, roof-mounted, and bed-mounted designs, highlighting real strengths and weaknesses. We considered weight capacity, ease of installation, security, and durability. Below are our top picks, with honest assessments of where each falls short and who should avoid them.
| Photo | Product | Score | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
|
🚗
|
Yakima SkyBox 21 Carbonite Best Roof-Mounted Cargo Box 21 cu ft capacity, 165 lb limit, fits most crossbars |
9.0 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Thule Motion XT XL Premium Roof Box with Smart Features 22 cu ft capacity, 165 lb limit, PowerClick quick-mount |
8.7 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
CURT 18105 Trailer Hitch Cargo Carrier Best Hitch-Mounted Basket 60 x 24 inch platform, 500 lb capacity, 2 inch receiver |
8.4 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
MaxxHaul 70115 Hitch Mount Cargo Carrier Budget-Friendly Hitch Carrier 60 x 20 inch platform, 500 lb capacity, fits 2 inch receiver |
7.8 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Rola 59504 V-Tech Roof Top Cargo Basket Adaptable Roof Basket for Trucks 49 x 37 x 6 inch basket, 150 lb capacity, fits crossbars |
8.1 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
TracRac TracONE Truck Bed Cargo Management System Best Bed-Mounted Cargo System Adjustable bed divider, 500 lb capacity, fits full-size trucks |
7.3 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
AA Products Hitch Mount Cargo Carrier with Ramp Multi-Function Carrier with Ramp 60 x 20 inch platform, 500 lb capacity, includes folding ramp |
7.6 | 🛒 Check Price |
1. Yakima SkyBox 21 Carbonite: Best Roof-Mounted Cargo Box
In our evaluation, the Yakima SkyBox 21 Carbonite stands out as a premium roof-mounted cargo box for truck owners with a cap or rack. Based on the spec sheet, its 21 cubic feet capacity and 165-pound weight limit make it ideal for bulky but lightweight gear like camping equipment or skis. Owner feedback consistently praises the low wind noise and easy mounting via the QuickRelease system. However, the high price tag and necessity of a roof rack system mean it is not a universal solution.
A real limitation is that the SkyBox cannot be used on trucks without a cap or aftermarket crossbars. Additionally, the 165-pound limit may be insufficient for heavier items like toolboxes. We recommend this carrier for outdoor enthusiasts who prioritize aerodynamics and security. If you need to carry heavy loads or lack roof rails, consider a hitch-mounted alternative.
- Aerodynamic design reduces wind noise and drag on the highway.
- Dual-side opening allows access from either side of the truck.
- Integrated QuickRelease mounting system for easy install and removal.
Pros: Excellent build quality and weather sealing.; Low-profile appearance with low profile.
Cons: Requires roof crossbars, not compatible with all truck caps.
2. Thule Motion XT XL: Premium Roof Box with Smart Features
We compared the Thule Motion XT XL and found it to be a top contender for roof-mounted cargo. Its 22 cubic feet capacity and 165-pound limit mirror the Yakima, but the SlideLock and PowerClick systems offer added convenience and security. Owner feedback highlights the ease of installation and sturdy construction. However, the price is among the highest in its class, making it a better investment for frequent travelers.
The main downside is cost; for those who only carry cargo a few times a year, a more affordable hitch basket might be better. Also, like all roof boxes, it reduces fuel economy and requires a rack. We suggest this for truck owners with a cap who want a premium, long-term solution. If budget is a concern, skip this pick.
- SlideLock system automatically locks the lid when closed.
- Dual-side opening with spring-loaded struts for easy loading.
- Fits most factory and aftermarket roof racks.
Pros: Very secure locking mechanism.; Smooth opening and closing action.
Cons: Expensive; value is lower for occasional use.
3. CURT 18105 Trailer Hitch Cargo Carrier: Best Hitch-Mounted Basket
Our research into hitch-mounted carriers led us to the CURT 18105, a sturdy basket that offers excellent value. With a 500-pound capacity and a 60×24 inch platform, it can handle heavy loads like furniture or camping gear. Owner reviews often mention the solid build and easy assembly. However, the large platform can obstruct the rear camera and license plate, which may require an accessory light bar and plate mount for legal road use.
Another limitation is that the carrier adds length to your truck, making parking more difficult. It also reduces departure angle for off-road use. We recommend this for truck owners with a 2-inch receiver who need to carry heavy, bulky items and don’t mind the extra length. If you frequently off-road or need rear visibility, consider a smaller basket or roof box.
- Large platform accommodates bulky items like coolers and luggage.
- Folded down design when not in use for easy storage.
- Rigid steel construction with black powder coat finish.
Pros: High weight capacity at a moderate price.; Folds up for compact storage.
Cons: Large size can block rear view and license plate.
4. MaxxHaul 70115 Hitch Mount Cargo Carrier: Budget-Friendly Hitch Carrier
The MaxxHaul 70115 is a popular budget option we evaluated. It offers the same 500-pound capacity as premium carriers at a fraction of the cost. Owner feedback indicates it works well for light to moderate use, such as hauling luggage or camping gear. However, the powder coat finish is less durable than higher-end models, and some users report rust after a few seasons. The lack of anti-rattle hardware can lead to noise on rough roads.
We recommend this carrier for occasional users on a tight budget who don’t need the highest durability. If you plan to use it frequently or in harsh environments, investing in a CURT or similar with better coating is wiser. Also, ensure your hitch has sufficient tongue weight capacity, as the carrier itself is heavy.
- Affordable price point for a full-size platform.
- Folding design for storage when not in use.
- Includes built-in tie-down hooks.
Pros: Very budget-friendly compared to competitors.; Solid weight capacity for the price.
Cons: Powder coat finish may chip over time.; No anti-rattle hardware included.
5. Rola 59504 V-Tech Roof Top Cargo Basket: All-around Roof Basket for Trucks
We researched the Rola 59504 V-Tech and found it to be a flexible roof basket for truck caps or racks. Its 150-pound capacity is lower than many hitch carriers, but the expandable design allows carrying longer items like ladders or canoes. Owner reviews appreciate the included wind fairing that reduces noise. However, the basket is open, so cargo is exposed to weather and theft unless you add a cover or net.
The main limitation is the weight capacity, which may be insufficient for heavy gear. Additionally, installation requires crossbars, which not all trucks have. We suggest this for truck owners with a cap who need to carry odd-shaped or long items. If you need higher capacity or weather protection, consider a cargo box or hitch carrier.
- Unique V-Tech design with removable extension for extra length.
- Wind fairing reduces drag and noise.
- Easy installation with universal mounting hardware.
Pros: Expandable length for longer items like kayaks.; Good value for the versatility.
Cons: Lower weight capacity than some competitors.; Not weatherproof; cargo needs covering.
6. TracRac TracONE Truck Bed Cargo Management System: Best Bed-Mounted Cargo System
We evaluated the TracRac TracONE as a bed-mounted alternative to external carriers. It uses a sliding divider to secure cargo within the truck bed, which is great for preventing items from sliding. The 500-pound capacity is generous, and the tie-down cleats add versatility. However, the price is high relative to its simplicity, and installation involves drilling, which may void some truck warranties.
Owner feedback is mixed: some love the organization, while others find it overpriced and limiting because it only works with items that fit within the bed. If you need to carry long or oversized items, a roof or hitch carrier is better. We recommend this only for truck owners who prioritize bed organization and have a budget for a premium system. Most users will find a hitch carrier more practical.
- Sliding and locking divider keeps cargo secure in the bed.
- Integrated tie-down cleats for securing loads.
- Quick-release handles for tool-free adjustment.
Pros: Keeps cargo organized and prevents shifting.; Heavy-duty construction.
Cons: Expensive for what is essentially a divider.; Installation requires drilling into the bed.
7. AA Products Hitch Mount Cargo Carrier with Ramp: Multi-Function Carrier with Ramp
We looked at the AA Products carrier with ramp as a unique option. It combines a standard hitch platform with a folding ramp, which is useful for loading motorcycles, lawnmowers, or heavy boxes. Owner feedback highlights the ramp’s convenience, but some report hinge issues after repeated use. The carrier itself is heavy, which reduces available tongue weight.
A real limitation is that the ramp adds complexity and potential failure points. For those who don’t need a ramp, a simpler carrier offers better durability. We recommend this for truck owners who frequently load heavy items and value the ramp feature. If you only carry lightweight cargo, skip this and choose a lighter, simpler basket.
- Integrated ramp folds out for easy loading of heavy items.
- Ramp also serves as a tailgate extender.
- Fits 2 inch receiver with anti-rattle bolt.
Pros: Ramp makes loading heavy items much easier.; Multi-purpose design for multiple uses.
Cons: Ramp hinge may wear over time.; Heavier than standard carriers, reducing payload.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best type of cargo carrier for a truck?
The best type depends on your needs. Hitch-mounted carriers offer high weight capacity and easy access, but can block rear visibility. Roof-mounted boxes are aerodynamic and secure, but require a rack and reduce fuel economy. Bed-mounted systems keep cargo in the bed but limit space. We recommend hitch carriers for heavy or bulky items, roof boxes for weather-sensitive gear, and bed systems for organization.
How much weight can a truck cargo carrier hold?
Weight capacity varies by model and mounting method. Hitch carriers typically support 300-500 pounds, but must not exceed your vehicle’s tongue weight rating (usually 500-1000 pounds for Class III hitches). Roof boxes and baskets usually max out at 150-165 pounds due to roof load limits. Always check your truck’s owner manual and the carrier’s specifications before loading.
Will a cargo carrier affect my truck's fuel economy?
Yes, any external cargo carrier increases aerodynamic drag, reducing fuel economy. Hitch carriers cause moderate drag, especially with tall items. Roof boxes and baskets create significant drag, often reducing MPG by 10-25% at highway speeds. Using a wind fairing can help. If fuel economy is critical, consider a bed-mounted system or a topper.
Do I need a special hitch for a cargo carrier?
Most hitch carriers require a 2-inch receiver hitch. Some smaller carriers fit 1.25-inch receivers, but many trucks come with 2-inch. Ensure your hitch’s tongue weight rating exceeds the carrier’s loaded weight. For heavy carriers, a weight-distributing hitch may be needed. Always verify compatibility before purchase.
How do I secure cargo on a hitch carrier?
Use high-quality ratchet straps or cam buckle straps to secure items to the carrier. Many carriers have built-in tie-down loops. For open baskets, consider a cargo net or cover. Also, use a hitch lock to prevent theft of the carrier itself. Ensure the load is balanced and does not exceed the carrier’s weight limit.
Our Verdict
After comparing specifications and owner feedback, we recommend the Yakima SkyBox 21 Carbonite for truck owners with a roof rack who prioritize aerodynamics and security. For most users, the CURT 18105 hitch carrier offers the best balance of capacity, durability, and value. Consider your truck’s setup and primary use before deciding.
More Truck Accessories Guides
Video Guide
Video: Related tutorial from YouTube