We researched and compared the top cargo carriers for SUVs, evaluating manufacturer specifications, safety standards, and aggregated owner feedback. Our guide covers roof baskets, hitch-mounted platforms, and soft bags to help you choose the right one for your needs.
We focused on key factors: weight capacity, ease of installation, aerodynamics, security features, and durability. Each product was scored based on performance, durability, value, ease of use, and safety. Here are our findings.
| Photo | Product | Score | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
|
🚗
|
Yakima LoadWarrior Best Overall Roof Basket Weight capacity: 165 lbs, Dimensions: 50 x 40 x 6.5 in, Weight: 45 lbs |
9.0 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Thule Motion XT XXL Best Hard-Shell Cargo Box Capacity: 22 cu ft, Dimensions: 92.5 x 35.5 x 17.5 in, Weight: 55 lbs |
9.2 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
CURT 18115 Hitch Cargo Carrier Best Hitch-Mounted Platform Weight capacity: 500 lbs, Platform size: 60 x 21 in, Weight: 38 lbs |
8.7 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Rightline Gear SUV Cargo Bag Best Soft Roof Bag Capacity: 18 cu ft, Dimensions: 60 x 40 x 18 in, Weight: 10 lbs |
8.3 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
Smittybilt 29206 Roof Basket Best for Off-Road Use Weight capacity: 250 lbs, Dimensions: 56 x 44 x 6 in, Weight: 55 lbs |
8.1 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
MaxxHaul 70215 Hitch Cargo Carrier Best Budget Hitch Carrier Weight capacity: 500 lbs, Platform size: 60 x 20 in, Weight: 28 lbs |
7.8 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
SportRack Vista XL Cargo Box Best Value Hard-Shell Box Capacity: 16 cu ft, Dimensions: 84 x 34 x 17 in, Weight: 42 lbs |
7.3 | 🛒 Check Price |
1. Yakima LoadWarrior: Best Overall Roof Basket
In our evaluation, the Yakima LoadWarrior stands out for its balance of aerodynamics, durability, and expandability. The spec sheet shows a 165 lb capacity, and owner feedback consistently praises its low wind noise and secure mounting system. The rubber-coated crossbar pads prevent scratching, and the integrated tie-downs make loading straightforward.
However, the LoadWarrior is one of the pricier options, and it does require existing crossbars. If your SUV lacks factory crossbars, you’ll need to factor in that extra cost. Also, the basket’s size may be too large for some compact SUVs, so measure your roof before purchasing. Those on a tight budget or with limited roof space might skip this pick.
- Aerodynamic design reduces wind noise and drag, evaluated by manufacturer.
- Integrated tie-down loops and rubber-coated crossbar pads protect gear.
- Expandable with optional extension and accessories like bike mounts.
Pros: Excellent build quality and sturdy construction.; Low profile design enhances fuel efficiency compared to other baskets.
Cons: Higher price point than many competitors.; Requires crossbars which are sold separately.
2. Thule Motion XT XXL: Best Hard-Shell Cargo Box
We researched the Thule Motion XT XXL and found it to be the premium choice for those needing maximum enclosed storage. Its 22 cubic foot capacity can hold multiple suitcases or bulky gear, and the dual-side opening is a convenience we noted in many owner reviews. The PowerGrip mounting system is tool-free and secure, meeting Thule’s high safety standards.
That said, the Motion XT XXL is a very expensive cargo carriers on the market. Its weight (55 lbs) makes it challenging to mount and remove alone, and storage when off the car requires significant space. If your budget is limited or you don’t need that much volume, consider a smaller box or a soft bag. This pick is best for frequent long-distance travelers with a large SUV.
- Dual-side opening allows loading from either side of the vehicle.
- PowerGrip quick-mount system for tool-free installation on crossbars.
- Integrated lock and key system for security.
Pros: Massive storage capacity ideal for family trips.; Aerodynamic shape minimizes drag and wind noise.
Cons: Very expensive; a significant investment.; Heavy and bulky to store when not in use.
3. CURT 18115 Hitch Cargo Carrier: Best Hitch-Mounted Platform
Based on our comparison of hitch carriers, the CURT 18115 offers exceptional value and capacity. The spec sheet indicates a 500 lb limit, and owner feedback confirms it handles heavy coolers, camping gear, and moving boxes well. The anti-rattle bolt and raised edges add stability and security.
However, users report that the platform can block the rear license plate and taillights if not properly positioned, which may require a light kit. Also, the carrier extends the vehicle’s length, making parking and backing up trickier. If you frequently need to access your trunk or have a short hitch, this may not be ideal. Those who prioritize rear visibility might prefer a roof carrier.
- Fits 2-inch hitch receivers; includes anti-rattle bolt for stability.
- Folded steel construction with black powder coat finish.
- Integrated tie-down loops and raised edges to prevent cargo shifting.
Pros: Very high weight capacity (500 lbs) for heavy loads.; Easy to install and remove; folds up for compact storage.
Cons: Can obstruct rear view and backup camera.; May reduce ground clearance on steep driveways.
4. Rightline Gear SUV Cargo Bag: Best Soft Roof Bag
In our evaluation of soft roof bags, the Rightline Gear SUV Cargo Bag is a top contender for budget-conscious buyers. Its waterproof construction and universal fit are frequently praised in owner reviews. The bag attaches via straps that loop inside the doors, which works on most SUVs without crossbars. We found the 18 cubic foot capacity sufficient for a family’s luggage.
However, soft bags have inherent weaknesses: they offer less security against theft and weather, and the material can wear over time. Some users reported flapping at highway speeds, which can be noisy. If you need to carry valuables or drive in extreme weather, a hard-shell box is a better choice. This bag is best for occasional use or short trips where budget is a priority.
- Waterproof 600D polyester with welded seams and rain flap.
- Universal fit with adjustable straps and door anchor loops.
- Packs down small for storage when not in use.
Pros: Very affordable compared to hard-shell boxes.; Lightweight and easy to install without crossbars.
Cons: Less secure than hard carriers; can be cut or accessed.; Not as aerodynamic; may cause wind noise and drag.
5. Smittybilt 29206 Roof Basket: Best for Off-Road Use
We researched the Smittybilt 29206 as a rugged option for off-road enthusiasts. Its steel mesh floor and high weight capacity (250 lbs) are backed by owner feedback from overlanding communities. The basket is built to handle rough trails and heavy loads like recovery gear and camping equipment.
However, this basket is heavy (55 lbs) and lacks aerodynamic features, leading to wind noise and reduced fuel economy. Installation is more complex than some competitors, and it requires compatible crossbars. If you primarily drive on pavement, a lighter, more aerodynamic basket like the Yakima LoadWarrior would be better. This pick is for serious off-roaders who prioritize durability over convenience.
- Heavy-duty steel construction with black powder coat.
- Expanded metal mesh floor prevents small items from falling.
- Includes 4 tie-down hooks and rubber mounting pads.
Pros: Extremely rugged and durable for off-road conditions.; Large platform can carry bulky gear like gas cans and shovels.
Cons: Very heavy; requires two people to install.; No wind fairing included; can be noisy at highway speeds.
6. MaxxHaul 70215 Hitch Cargo Carrier: Best Budget Hitch Carrier
Based on our comparison, the MaxxHaul 70215 offers the best value for those needing a hitch carrier on a tight budget. With a 500 lb capacity and a large platform, it can handle heavy loads. Owner reviews note it is easy to assemble and install, making it a popular choice for occasional use.
However, the lower price comes with trade-offs. The finish is less durable than premium brands, and some users report rust after a few months. The lack of an anti-rattle bolt can cause wobbling, which may be annoying. For frequent or heavy-duty use, the CURT 18115 is a better investment. This carrier is suitable for light, occasional hauling where cost is the primary concern.
- Fits 2-inch hitch receivers; includes pin and clip.
- Folded steel platform with raised edges and tie-down slots.
- Lightweight design for easy handling.
Pros: Very low price point for the capacity.; Lightweight and easy to install.
Cons: Powder coat finish may chip over time.; No anti-rattle mechanism; can wobble on rough roads.
7. SportRack Vista XL Cargo Box: Best Value Hard-Shell Box
In our evaluation, the SportRack Vista XL is a budget-friendly hard-shell cargo box that offers many features of pricier models. The dual-side opening and tool-free mount are convenient, and the 16 cubic foot capacity is adequate for a week-long trip. Owner feedback generally positive for the price.
However, we noted that the build quality is not on par with Thule or Yakima. Some users experienced cracks in the shell after a few seasons, and the locking mechanism can be temperamental. If you plan to use it frequently or in harsh conditions, spending more on a premium box is advisable. The Vista XL is a good entry-level option for occasional use and mild climates.
- Dual-side opening for convenient loading.
- Tool-free mounting system with quick-release levers.
- Central locking system with keys.
Pros: Affordable price for a hard-shell box.; Decent capacity for family trips.
Cons: Plastic shell feels less durable than premium brands.; Latch mechanism reported to be finicky by some users.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best type of cargo carrier for an SUV?
The best type depends on your needs. Roof baskets are great for bulky, oddly shaped items and keep your rear view clear. Hard-shell cargo boxes offer weatherproof, secure storage and better aerodynamics. Hitch-mounted platforms are easiest to load and have high weight capacity but can block rear access. Soft roof bags are the most affordable and lightweight but offer less security.
How much weight can an SUV cargo carrier hold?
Weight capacity varies by product and vehicle. Roof racks typically hold 100-165 lbs, but your vehicle’s roof dynamic load limit (often 100-200 lbs) is the real constraint. Hitch carriers can hold up to 500 lbs, but you must also consider your hitch’s tongue weight rating (usually 350-500 lbs). Always check your SUV’s manual and the carrier’s specs.
Will a cargo carrier affect my fuel economy?
Yes, any cargo carrier increases drag and reduces fuel economy. Roof carriers, especially baskets, cause the most drag (5-25% reduction). Hard-shell boxes are more aerodynamic but still impact MPG. Hitch carriers have less aerodynamic effect but add weight. Soft bags also increase drag. Expect a noticeable decrease, especially at highway speeds.
Do I need crossbars for a roof cargo carrier?
Most roof baskets and hard-shell boxes require crossbars to mount. Some SUVs come with factory crossbars, but many do not. If your vehicle lacks them, you’ll need to purchase a set compatible with your roof rails. Soft roof bags often use straps that loop inside the doors and do not require crossbars.
How do I secure cargo in a carrier?
Use integrated tie-down points, straps, or bungee cords to secure items. For roof baskets, a cargo net or cover can prevent items from shifting. In hard-shell boxes, distribute weight evenly and use the box’s internal straps if provided. For hitch carriers, use ratchet straps and ensure the load doesn’t exceed the carrier’s edges. Always double-check security before driving.
Our Verdict
After researching and comparing specifications and owner feedback, our top pick is the Yakima LoadWarrior for its excellent balance of aerodynamics, durability, and expandability. For those needing enclosed, weatherproof storage, the Thule Motion XT XXL is the best premium choice. The CURT 18115 Hitch Cargo Carrier is our runner-up for its high capacity and value, ideal for heavy loads without roof access.
More Car Accessories Guides
Video Guide
Video: Related tutorial from YouTube