Finding the right crate for a puppy involves balancing safety, comfort, and containment during travel. We researched manufacturer specifications and aggregated owner feedback to identify which crates actually secure a puppy effectively in a moving vehicle.
Our evaluation focuses on crash safety ratings where available, material durability, and ease of cleaning. We compared wire, plastic, and heavy-duty options to help you find the best fit for your specific vehicle and breed.
| Photo | Product | Score | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
 |
Gunner Kennels G1 Intermediate Editor's Choice Double wall rotomolded polyethylene |
9.1 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
Petmate Two Door Top Load Best for Puppies Top loading door design |
8.5 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
MidWest Homes for Pets iCrate Best Wire Value Includes adjustable divider panel |
8.1 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
SmithBuilt Heavy Duty Most Secure 20 gauge steel construction |
7.8 | 🛒 Check Price |
 |
Snoozer Roll Around Best for Small Cars Washable faux lambswool liner |
7.4 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Amazon Basics Folding Metal Dog Crate Budget Pick Electro coat finish for rust resistance |
7.2 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Petmate Vari Kennel Classic Plastic Airline approved design |
6.9 | 🛒 Check Price |
1. Gunner Kennels G1 Intermediate: Editor's Choice
Our research indicates that the Gunner Kennels G1 sets the standard for safety in the industry. It is one of the few crates independently evaluated to withstand high impact forces. The double wall rotomolded plastic provides excellent insulation and protection, making it a top choice for owners who prioritize crash safety above all else.
However, the weight of this crate is a significant limitation. It is difficult to move in and out of a vehicle without assistance. We recommend this product for owners who intend to leave the crate permanently in the vehicle or for those who do not mind the heavy lifting.
- High strength construction for crash protection
- Integrated floor drain system
- Non corrosive stainless steel latch pins
Pros: Unmatched durability and safety features; Escape proof design with heavy duty latching
Cons: Significantly heavier than other models
2. Petmate Two Door Top Load: Best for Puppies
In our evaluation of portable options, the Petmate Two Door Top Load stands out for its convenience. The top loading door is a standout for puppies who are hesitant to enter a crate, allowing owners to gently lower them in. The plastic shell is easy to wipe down, which is essential for accidents during potty training.
While the wire doors are sturdy, the plastic body is not as resistant to chewing as metal options. Based on owner feedback, this crate is best suited for calm puppies or for supervised travel. It is not recommended for dogs with separation anxiety or a history of destructive chewing.
- Easy access top door for small breeds
- Ventilation holes on all sides
- Durable plastic construction with metal wire doors
Pros: Top door makes placing puppies inside very easy; Lightweight and easy to clean
Cons: Plastic sides may be chewed by determined puppies
3. MidWest Homes for Pets iCrate: Best Wire Value
The MidWest iCrate is a ubiquitous choice that offers great value. We found that the included divider panel is its strongest asset, allowing you to buy the correct adult size for your dog breed while restricting space for the puppy. This adaptability extends the life of the product significantly.
Despite its popularity, the wire construction presents some drawbacks for car travel. The metal frame can rattle loudly while driving, which may startle a nervous puppy. Additionally, the wire floor can be harsh on paws, so purchasing a separate bed or pad is a necessary step for comfort.
- Folding design for portability and storage
- Double door access for versatility
- Pan included for easy cleaning
Pros: Divider panel allows the crate to grow with the puppy; Excellent ventilation for airflow
Cons: Wire floor can be uncomfortable without padding
4. SmithBuilt Heavy Duty: Most Secure
For owners of escape artists, the SmithBuilt Heavy Duty crate is a formidable solution. We compared its gauge steel to standard wire crates and found it to be significantly thicker. The reinforced frame and tight welds prevent even the most determined dogs from bending the bars or breaking out.
The trade off for this security is weight and ease of use. This crate is cumbersome to fold and transport. Also, some user reviews mention sharp edges on the welds, which require careful inspection before placing a puppy inside. We suggest this for powerful breeds only.
- Welded steel frame for maximum strength
- Lockable wheels for mobility
- Two slide bolt latches per door
Pros: Extremely difficult for dogs to escape; High strength steel prevents bending
Cons: Very heavy and difficult to move alone
5. Snoozer Roll Around: Best for Small Cars
The Snoozer Roll Around is a soft sided crate that maximizes comfort and portability. Based on our analysis, it is ideal for small breeds and puppies that need a cozy den. The included faux lambswool liner is a nice touch that provides a sense of security, and the wheels make moving it through airports or hotels easy.
Crucially, this crate lacks structural integrity. In a collision, it offers zero protection for the animal. It is also susceptible to damage from chewing. We recommend this product only for small, calm dogs in low risk environments or for use as a temporary indoor den.
- Wheels for easy transport
- Compact size fits in smaller vehicles
- Multiple mesh doors for ventilation
Pros: Very comfortable bedding included; Easy to move when folded
Cons: Soft sides offer no crash protection
6. Amazon Basics Folding Metal Dog Crate: Budget Pick
We evaluated the Amazon Basics Folding Metal Crate as a functional, no frills option. It provides the basic containment a puppy needs at a very accessible price point. The electro coat finish helps prevent rust, and the plastic pan is easy to remove for cleaning accidents.
Our main concern lies in the latching mechanism. The single latch system is flimsy compared to the dual latches found on more expensive models. A smart puppy might learn to nudge it open. Additionally, the thinner gauge wire makes it less suitable for travel safety compared to the SmithBuilt or Gunner models.
- Simple fold and carry assembly
- Plastic pan for easy cleaning
- Single door access
Pros: Very affordable entry level option; Lightweight enough for most people to carry
Cons: Latches are not as secure as other models
7. Petmate Vari Kennel: Classic Plastic
The Petmate Vari Kennel is a classic design that has been around for decades. It is airline approved and features a durable plastic shell. Our comparison shows it is more durable than the softer plastic carriers, making it a viable option for travel that meets strict airline regulations.
However, the assembly process is tedious as it requires screws and wing nuts to secure the top and bottom halves. The ventilation is also limited compared to wire crates, which can make the interior warm. We suggest this for occasional travelers or those needing an airline compliant carrier, but not for daily use in hot climates.
- Plastic shell with metal vents
- Assembly required with wing nuts
- Heavy duty plastic handles
Pros: Fits most airline cargo requirements; Denser plastic than budget carriers
Cons: Requires assembly with screws and nuts
Frequently Asked Questions
What size crate should I get for my puppy?
The crate should be large enough for your puppy to stand, turn around, and lie down. However, for car travel, smaller is often safer to prevent injury from sudden stops. We recommend using a divider panel to limit space while the puppy grows.
Are wire crates safe for car travel?
Wire crates offer excellent ventilation but can collapse or bend in an accident. If using a wire crate, ensure it is secured with straps or anchors and choose a heavy duty model with thicker gauge steel to resist deformation.
How do I secure a dog crate in my car?
Most crates should be secured using metal tie down straps or specific cargo anchors. Never rely solely on the seatbelt around a plastic crate unless the manufacturer explicitly designs it for that configuration. Check your vehicle manual for cargo restraint points.
Should I use a soft crate or a hard crate for a puppy?
Hard crates made of plastic or metal are generally safer for puppies that are not yet potty trained or are prone to chewing. Soft crates offer comfort but provide no protection in a crash and can be easily destroyed by teething puppies.
Can I leave my puppy in the crate while driving?
Yes, a crate is the safest way for a puppy to travel. It prevents the driver from being distracted and keeps the puppy contained during sudden braking. Ensure the crate is well ventilated and never leave the puppy alone in a hot car.
Our Verdict
Our top pick is the Gunner Kennels G1 Intermediate for its superior safety ratings and strong construction. For those needing a more budget friendly option specifically for small puppies, the Petmate Two Door Top Load offers excellent accessibility and value.
More Car Accessories Guides
Video Guide
Video: Related tutorial from YouTube