We researched and compared the top roof boxes available, evaluating manufacturer specifications, published safety standards, and aggregated owner feedback. This guide highlights the strengths and limitations of each model to help you choose a box that fits your vehicle and needs.
| Photo | Product | Score | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
|
🚗
|
Thule Motion XT XL Top Pick 16 cu ft capacity, dual-side opening, MaxLoad 165 lb |
9.0 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Yakima SkyBox 16 Carbonite Runner Up 16 cu ft capacity, dual-side opening, MaxLoad 165 lb |
8.7 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
SportRack Vista XL Best Value 15 cu ft capacity, rear opening, MaxLoad 110 lb |
8.4 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
INNO Wedge 660 Compact Choice 11 cu ft capacity, rear opening, MaxLoad 75 lb |
8.1 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Rhino-Rack MasterFit XT All-around Fit 13 cu ft capacity, dual-side opening, MaxLoad 110 lb |
8.3 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Goplus Roof Cargo Carrier Budget Pick 15 cu ft capacity, rear opening, MaxLoad 110 lb |
7.8 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Rightline Gear Range 2 Soft-Sided Alternative 11 cu ft capacity, rear opening, MaxLoad 75 lb |
7.3 | 🛒 Check Price |
1. Thule Motion XT XL: Top Pick
The Thule Motion XT XL stands out for its refined aerodynamics and sturdy construction. In our evaluation, it offers one of the best balances of cargo capacity and ease of use, with a tool-free mounting system that installs in minutes. Owner feedback consistently praises its low wind noise and secure locking mechanism, making it a reliable choice for frequent travelers.
However, the premium cost is a notable drawback. If you only need occasional cargo space or have a tighter budget, this box may be overkill. It also requires a roof rack with crossbars, so ensure compatibility before purchase.
- Dual-side opening for easy loading from either side of the vehicle
- Power-Click quick-mount system ensures secure and simple installation
- Aerodynamic design reduces wind noise and drag
Pros: Excellent build quality and security features; Low wind noise even at highway speeds
Cons: Premium price point may not suit all budgets
2. Yakima SkyBox 16 Carbonite: Runner Up
The Yakima SkyBox 16 Carbonite is a strong contender with its dual-side opening and integrated T-slots. We compared its specs to the Thule and found it offers similar capacity at a more accessible price. Owner feedback highlights the ease of opening and closing, though some report the gas struts can weaken after a few years.
This box is best for those who want the flexibility to mount additional gear. But if you prioritize absolute long-term durability over versatility, you might look elsewhere. It also performs well in wind noise tests, but not as quiet as the Thule Motion XT.
- Dual-side opening with gas struts for smooth operation
- Integrated T-slots for mounting accessories like bike racks
- HD-Lock system provides enhanced security against theft
Pros: Multi-purpose mounting options with T-slot channels; Good value for the feature set
Cons: Gas struts may lose pressure over time; Slightly heavier than some competitors
3. SportRack Vista XL: Best Value
The SportRack Vista XL offers solid performance at a budget-friendly price. In our research, it provides decent cargo space and a simple mounting system that works with many crossbars. Owner feedback notes it is a good entry-level box, but the 110 lb capacity means you can’t pack it with heavy items like camping gear or tools.
If you primarily need to carry lightweight items like blankets or clothing, this box is a smart choice. However, for heavier loads or frequent use, the lower durability and safety margins may be a concern. Consider upgrading if you plan to use it for road trips with substantial gear.
- Rear opening design for easy access from the back of the vehicle
- Aerodynamic shape reduces drag and wind noise
- Quick-mount U-bolts compatible with most factory racks
Pros: Affordable price without major compromises; Lightweight and easy to handle
Cons: Lower weight capacity limits heavy loads; Rear opening can be inconvenient for some users
4. INNO Wedge 660: Compact Choice
The INNO Wedge 660 is designed for drivers with smaller vehicles who need occasional extra space. We evaluated its dimensions and found it fits well on subcompact SUVs and sedans without overwhelming the roof. Owner feedback appreciates its low profile and ease of installation, but the small capacity (11 cu ft) and 75 lb limit mean it is best for short trips or lightweight gear.
If you frequently carry bulky items or travel with a family, this box will feel cramped. It is a niche product for those who prioritize compactness over volume. Safety is adequate but not outstanding, so avoid overloading.
- Compact size fits smaller vehicles and tight garages
- Aerodynamic wedge shape reduces wind resistance
- Tool-free mounting with quick-release brackets
Pros: Ideal for compact cars and low roof clearance; Lightweight and easy to store when not in use
Cons: Limited capacity for longer trips; Lower weight limit restricts heavy items
5. Rhino-Rack MasterFit XT: Flexible Fit
The Rhino-Rack MasterFit XT is a adaptable option that fits many crossbar configurations. We compared its mounting system to others and found it offers good adjustability, though some owners report a learning curve. The dual-side opening is convenient, but the box is not as wind-efficient as the Thule or Yakima, leading to slightly more noise at highway speeds.
This box suits those with non-standard roof racks or who need a durable, affordable solution. However, if you drive long distances at high speeds, the added wind noise may be a drawback. It also has a moderate 110 lb capacity, so it handles typical gear but not heavy loads.
- Adjustable mounting system fits plenty of crossbars
- Dual-side opening with central locking
- UV-resistant ABS construction for long life
Pros: Excellent compatibility with various roof racks; Sturdy and durable construction
Cons: Installation can be fiddly with some rack types; Not as aerodynamic as premium models
6. Goplus Roof Cargo Carrier: Budget Pick
The Goplus Roof Cargo Carrier is a soft-sided option that offers a low-cost way to add cargo space. In our evaluation, it provides generous volume but sacrifices security and durability. Owner feedback often mentions concerns about the strap system coming loose on long trips, and the fabric can show wear after a season of use.
This carrier is suitable for occasional, low-speed trips where you can monitor the load. It is not recommended for highway driving or valuable items. If you need a permanent, worry-free solution, invest in a hard-shell box instead.
- Large capacity at a low price point
- Simple strap and buckle mounting system
- Folds flat for storage when not in use
Pros: Very affordable for the size; Easy to store when not in use
Cons: Mounting system less secure than rigid boxes; Material may degrade in extreme weather
7. Rightline Gear Range 2: Soft-Sided Alternative
The Rightline Gear Range 2 is a soft-sided carrier that emphasizes waterproofing and portability. We researched its construction and found it holds up well in rain, but the strap mounting system is less reliable than hard shells. Owner feedback indicates that the straps need frequent retightening, and the 75 lb limit restricts what you can carry.
This is best for occasional use with light, waterproof gear like camping chairs or sleeping bags. It is not a substitute for a hard box if you carry heavy or valuable items. Safety is a concern at highway speeds, so use it cautiously.
- Waterproof PVC-coated fabric with welded seams
- Universal fit with adjustable straps and buckles
- Folds into a compact storage bag
Pros: Completely waterproof when properly sealed; Lightweight and packs away small
Cons: Strap system can loosen over bumps; Limited weight capacity and security
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I choose the right size roof box?
Measure your vehicle’s roof length and width between crossbars, then compare with the box’s dimensions. Also consider your typical cargo volume and ensure the box’s weight capacity exceeds your load. A box that is too large may overhang and affect aerodynamics or safety.
Can I install a roof box on any car?
Most cars with factory roof rails or aftermarket crossbars can mount a roof box. However, some vehicles with panoramic sunroofs or low weight limits may not be compatible. Always check the manufacturer’s fit guide and your vehicle’s roof load capacity.
Do roof boxes affect fuel economy?
Yes, any roof box increases aerodynamic drag, reducing fuel economy by 10-25% at highway speeds. Aerodynamic models like the Thule Motion XT minimize the impact. Removing the box when not in use helps restore efficiency.
How do I secure a roof box to prevent theft?
Use the integrated locking system that comes with most hard-shell boxes. Some models offer additional T-slot locks or padlocks. For soft carriers, consider a cable lock through the straps. Never leave valuables unattended in a roof box.
What is the maximum speed for driving with a roof box?
Most manufacturers recommend not exceeding 80 mph (130 km/h) with a roof box. Always follow the specific speed limit in the owner’s manual. At high speeds, wind noise increases and the load may shift, so moderate your speed.
Our Verdict
After researching and comparing the options, the Thule Motion XT XL earns our top pick for its superior aerodynamics, build quality, and ease of use. The Yakima SkyBox 16 Carbonite is a close runner up, offering similar features at a slightly lower price. Both provide excellent safety and durability for most users.
More Exterior Protection Guides
Video Guide
Video: Related tutorial from YouTube