If you own an ATV and need to break ground for a food plot, garden, or wildlife habitat, a pull behind disc is a smart investment. We researched and compared seven top-rated models based on manufacturer specifications, published industry standards, and aggregated owner feedback. Our evaluation focuses on performance, durability, value, ease of use, and safety to help you choose the right tool for your property.
| Photo | Product | Score | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
|
🚗
|
King Kutter 48-Inch ATV Disc Harrow Best Overall 48-inch cutting width, 14 notched discs, 150 lb. weight |
9 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
CountyLine 40-Inch ATV Disc Harrow Best Value 40-inch cutting width, 12 discs, 110 lb. weight |
8.7 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Tarter 48-Inch ATV Disc Harrow Heavy-Duty Pick 48-inch width, 16 discs (notched/smooth combo), 195 lb. weight |
8.4 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Field Tuff ATV Disc Harrow 44-Inch Compact Choice 44-inch cutting width, 12 notched discs, 130 lb. weight |
8.1 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Harrow Tech 60-Inch ATV Disc Harrow Wide Coverage 60-inch cutting width, 18 discs, 210 lb. weight |
7.8 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Agri-Fab 45-0466 48-Inch Tow Behind Disc Lawn Tractor Compatible 48-inch width, 12 discs, 95 lb. weight, designed for lawn tractors |
7.3 | 🛒 Check Price |
|
🚗
|
Massey Ferguson 40-Inch ATV Disc Harrow Budget Option 40-inch width, 10 discs, 85 lb. weight |
7 | 🛒 Check Price |
1. King Kutter 48-Inch ATV Disc Harrow: Best Overall
In our evaluation, the King Kutter 48-Inch ATV Disc Harrow stands out for its strong construction and effective soil breaking capability. The 14 notched discs and adjustable gang angle let you fine-tune the depth for different soil conditions, from light tilling to breaking new ground. Owner feedback consistently praises its durability, with many reporting years of reliable service on food plots and gardens. The powder coat finish helps prevent rust, though some users noted it can chip over time if used on rocky terrain.
However, this disc is heavy and may cause the ATV to struggle on steep inclines or in very wet soil. It is best for flat to gently sloping land. If you have a small ATV (under 350cc) or primarily work on soft, sandy soil, a lighter model might be easier to handle. Also, the disc’s width requires adequate turning space, so it may not suit tight areas.
- 14 notched discs provide aggressive soil penetration for tough ground
- Adjustable gang angle allows for varying depth and cutting aggressiveness
- Heavy-duty steel frame with powder coat finish resists rust
Pros: Excellent build quality for the price point; Easy to adjust disc angle without tools
Cons: Requires a high-clearance ATV to avoid dragging in deep soil
2. CountyLine 40-Inch ATV Disc Harrow: Best Value
The CountyLine 40-Inch ATV Disc Harrow earned our Best Value pick because it offers solid performance at a lower investment. We compared its specs to pricier models and found it capable of preparing seedbeds in loamy or sandy soils. The 12 smooth discs work well for secondary tillage and light cultivation. Owner feedback highlights its ease of assembly and straightforward operation, making it a good choice for beginners.
However, the smooth discs lack the aggressive cutting of notched discs, so breaking up hard-packed or rocky ground may require multiple passes. If you need to till virgin sod or heavy clay, you might find this disc underpowered. Also, the frame is lighter, which can lead to bouncing at higher speeds. It’s best for maintenance tilling on already-worked land.
- Compact 40-inch width fits smaller ATVs and tight spaces
- 12 smooth discs with adjustable gang angle for flexible tilling
- Lightweight design (110 lbs) reduces strain on the ATV
Pros: Great value for budget-conscious buyers; Easy to assemble and attach to ATV hitch
Cons: Smooth discs may not cut through hard clay as effectively as notched discs
3. Tarter 48-Inch ATV Disc Harrow: Heavy-Duty Pick
The Tarter 48-Inch ATV Disc Harrow is built for serious work. In our evaluation, its combination of notched and smooth discs allows it to cut through sod and then smooth the soil in one pass. The frame is noticeably solid, with welded gussets that resist flexing under load. Owner feedback from farmers and land managers confirms it stands up to rocky fields and repeated use without bending. The transport lock is a nice safety feature for road travel.
That said, this disc is heavy at 195 pounds, and many users report that a smaller ATV struggles to pull it effectively, especially uphill. If your ATV is under 500cc or you work on steep terrain, this model may be too much. It also comes at a higher price, so budget-minded buyers may want to consider lighter alternatives.
- 16 disc combination (8 notched, 8 smooth) for aggressive cutting and smoothing
- Heavy-duty steel frame with reinforced gussets for longevity
- Adjustable gang angles and transport lock for safe towing
Pros: Excellent build quality and durability for tough conditions; Combination discs handle both breaking ground and finishing
Cons: Heavy weight requires a larger ATV (500cc+) for effective use
4. Field Tuff ATV Disc Harrow 44-Inch: Compact Choice
The Field Tuff 44-Inch ATV Disc Harrow is a solid mid-range option for those with smaller ATVs or limited storage. We researched its specs and found that the notched discs help it dig into soil better than smooth-disc models of similar size. Owner feedback indicates it works well for food plots and garden prep in moderate soil conditions. The adjustable hitch allows you to fine-tune the disc angle for depth control.
However, some owners have noted that the frame can flex when hitting rocks or roots, which may affect longevity. If you have rocky soil, a heavier-duty model like the Tarter might be a better investment. Also, the 44-inch width may not cover ground as quickly as larger discs, but it’s a good trade-off for maneuverability.
- Notched discs for better cutting in hard soil
- Compact size fits smaller ATVs and tight spaces
- Adjustable hitch height for level operation
Pros: Notched discs provide good penetration for its size; Light enough for most utility ATVs (350cc+)
Cons: Frame flex reported by some users on uneven ground
5. Harrow Tech 60-Inch ATV Disc Harrow: Wide Coverage
The Harrow Tech 60-Inch ATV Disc Harrow is designed for those with large fields and powerful ATVs. We compared its coverage to narrower models and found it can significantly reduce tilling time. The 18 discs and adjustable angles allow you to customize the cut. Owner feedback notes that it works well in soft to moderately firm soil, and the wide span is ideal for food plots or hay field renovation.
However, durability concerns arise: several users reported bent discs or frame issues when used on rocky ground. The weight (210 lbs) also demands a high-horsepower ATV, and turning radius is limited. If your land is rocky or your ATV is under 600cc, you should look at lighter options. This disc is best for flat, open fields with consistent soil.
- Extra-wide 60-inch coverage for large plots
- 18 discs with adjustable gang angles
- Heavy frame requires a powerful ATV
Pros: Covers ground quickly for large areas; Adjustable disc angles for custom depth
Cons: Some owners report bent discs on rocky terrain; Very heavy; needs a large ATV (600cc+) to pull effectively
6. Agri-Fab 45-0466 48-Inch Tow Behind Disc: Lawn Tractor Compatible
The Agri-Fab 45-0466 is marketed as a tow-behind disc for lawn tractors, but it also works with small ATVs. In our evaluation, it is best for light-duty tasks like preparing a garden bed in already-tilled soil or spreading compost. The lightweight frame makes it easy to attach and maneuver. Owner feedback indicates it is simple to assemble and use, and it is one of the few discs that can be pulled by a riding mower.
However, its limitations are significant: the smooth discs do not cut into hard ground, and the frame is not built for rocky conditions. Several owners reported bent arms or broken welds when used on uneven terrain. If you need to break new ground or have rocky soil, this disc will disappoint. It is best for soft, prepared soil and small plots.
- Lightweight design (95 lbs) works with lawn tractors and small ATVs
- 12 smooth discs for light tilling and seedbed preparation
- Adjustable hitch height for level operation
Pros: Very lightweight and easy to handle; Can be used with lawn tractors, not just ATVs
Cons: Smooth discs struggle with hard or rocky soil; Frame may bend under heavy use
7. Massey Ferguson 40-Inch ATV Disc Harrow: Budget Option
The Massey Ferguson 40-Inch ATV Disc Harrow is the most budget-friendly model we researched. It is designed for very light work, such as smoothing soil or incorporating seed after tilling. Its simple construction means it is easy to assemble and hook up. Owner feedback suggests it works okay on soft, sandy soil but struggles with any resistance.
We found that the lack of adjustable gang angles and the smooth discs make it unsuitable for breaking new ground or heavy clay. The frame is also less durable; some users reported bending after a few uses on uneven terrain. This disc is best for those with small ATVs and very light soil preparation needs. If you have any serious tilling to do, we recommend spending a bit more on a model with notched discs and adjustable angles.
- Lowest weight (85 lbs) for easy towing by small ATVs
- 10 smooth discs for light tilling
- Basic design with no gang angle adjustment
Pros: Very affordable entry-level option; Lightweight and easy to store
Cons: No adjustable gang angle limits versatility; Smooth discs ineffective on hard or weedy ground
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use an ATV pull behind disc on my lawn tractor?
Most ATV discs are too heavy for lawn tractors and can damage the transmission. However, lightweight models like the Agri-Fab 45-0466 are specifically designed for lawn tractors and small ATVs. Always check the weight and hitch compatibility before use.
How do I choose the right size disc for my ATV?
Match the disc size to your ATV’s engine power and terrain. For ATVs under 400cc, a 40-44 inch disc weighing under 130 lbs is ideal. For 500cc and above, you can handle 48-60 inch discs weighing up to 200 lbs. Also consider your soil type: notched discs work better in hard soil.
What is the difference between notched and smooth discs?
Notched discs have serrated edges that cut aggressively into sod and hard soil, making them better for primary tillage. Smooth discs are gentler and used for secondary tillage, like smoothing seedbeds. Many discs combine both types for versatility.
Do I need to add weight to my ATV disc for better penetration?
Some discs have weight brackets for adding suitcase weights or sandbags. Adding weight can improve penetration in hard soil, but it also increases strain on your ATV. Check the manufacturer’s recommendations and your ATV’s towing capacity before adding weight.
How fast should I pull a disc behind my ATV?
For effective tilling, pull at a slow speed (2-4 mph). Faster speeds can cause bouncing, reduce soil penetration, and increase the risk of damage to the disc or ATV. Always follow the manufacturer’s speed guidelines.
Our Verdict
After researching and comparing specs, owner feedback, and industry standards, the King Kutter 48-Inch ATV Disc Harrow is our top pick for its balance of performance, durability, and value. For those on a tighter budget or with smaller ATVs, the CountyLine 40-Inch ATV Disc Harrow is an excellent runner-up that delivers reliable light-duty tilling without breaking the bank.
More Car Accessories Guides
Video Guide
Video: Related tutorial from YouTube